Harris Jacob A, Anyawire Mariamu, Mabulla Audax, Wood Brian M
School of Interdisciplinary Forensics, Arizona State University, Glendale, USA.
Hadza Fund, Mang'ola, Karatu, Tanzania.
Hum Nat. 2024 Sep;35(3):197-224. doi: 10.1007/s12110-024-09475-5. Epub 2024 Aug 20.
We present the first published ethnographic description of landscape burning by Hadza hunter-gatherers of northern Tanzania and identify environmental, social, and cultural influences on Hadza landscape burning, thereby broadening the ethnographic record of anthropogenic burning practices described for hunter-gatherer communities. We report interview data collected in 2022 and 2023, describing their practices and attitudes regarding the causes and consequences of burning. We provide context by comparing our observations with those recorded for hunting and gathering populations in Africa, Australia, and North America. Hadza landscape burning is generally a solitary and male-dominated activity, contrary to ethnographic accounts of Indigenous landscape burning from North America and Australia. The primary goals stated by Hadza for landscape burning were improved hunting, reduced hazards from dangerous animals, and to reduce the density of livestock. Firsthand observations suggest that landscape burning has decreased over the past 20 years, and this historical trend is supported by interviews. Satellite imagery also suggests an overall decrease in burning activity in the region from 2001 to 2022. Among the Hadza, landscape burning is a culturally influenced and strongly gender-biased activity that is rapidly disappearing. Because burning can radically transform landscapes, these practices often generate or amplify conflicts of interest between groups with different land use strategies. Hadza report serious social conflict with pastoralists over landscape burning, and our study suggests this tension has constrained the practice in the past two decades.
我们首次发表了对坦桑尼亚北部哈扎族狩猎采集者进行景观焚烧的人种志描述,并确定了对哈扎族景观焚烧产生影响的环境、社会和文化因素,从而拓宽了针对狩猎采集者群体所描述的人为焚烧行为的人种志记录。我们报告了在2022年和2023年收集的访谈数据,描述了他们对焚烧的原因和后果的做法及态度。我们通过将我们的观察结果与非洲、澳大利亚和北美的狩猎采集人群记录的观察结果进行比较来提供背景信息。与北美和澳大利亚关于本土景观焚烧的人种志描述相反,哈扎族的景观焚烧通常是一项由男性主导的单独活动。哈扎族表示进行景观焚烧的主要目标是改善狩猎条件、减少危险动物带来的危害以及降低牲畜密度。第一手观察表明,景观焚烧在过去20年中有所减少,访谈也支持了这一历史趋势。卫星图像还显示,2001年至2022年该地区的焚烧活动总体上有所减少。在哈扎族中,景观焚烧是一项受文化影响且性别偏见强烈的活动,正在迅速消失。由于焚烧会从根本上改变景观,这些做法往往会引发或加剧不同土地利用策略群体之间的利益冲突。哈扎族报告称,在景观焚烧问题上与牧民发生了严重的社会冲突,我们的研究表明,这种紧张关系在过去二十年中限制了这种做法。