Department of Surgery, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
Division of Orthopaedic Surgery, St. Joseph's Healthcare, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
Am J Sports Med. 2024 Sep;52(11):2860-2865. doi: 10.1177/03635465241270138. Epub 2024 Aug 21.
The management of pain after shoulder surgery typically includes the use of cryotherapy and the prescription of opioid analgesics. Much focus has been placed lately on the opioid epidemic, which in part is fueled by excessive prescription of opioid medication. Previous studies have found a combination of cryotherapy and compression effective at reducing analgesic consumption and increasing recovery in patients undergoing knee and spine surgery; however, efficacy in patients undergoing shoulder surgery has not been evaluated.
To evaluate the effectiveness of a cryo-pneumatic compression device on postoperative shoulder pain, narcotic use, and quality of life when compared with standard care cryotherapy.
Randomized controlled trial; Level of evidence, 2.
In total, 200 patients older than 18 years scheduled for unilateral shoulder surgery were enrolled. Patients were randomized to receive either postoperative cryo-pneumatic compression or standard care. The intervention group received a cryo-pneumatic device, while the standard care group received the treating surgeon's preferred method of postoperative care, including standard cryotherapy. Narcotic use was evaluated by the number of oral morphine milligram equivalents consumed during the postoperative period, as well as the time to cessation of narcotic use. Patient-reported outcome measures consisted of a numeric rating scale pain score, 36-item Short Form Survey, patient experience assessed using the net promoter score, and adverse events. Outcomes were evaluated at 2, 6, and 12 weeks postoperatively.
Patients receiving cryo-pneumatic compression reported a significant decrease in opioid consumption when compared with standard care (oral morphine milligram equivalents median, 56.1 vs 112; = .02468). A significant increase in self-reported function was seen in the cryo-pneumatic compression group at 2 weeks when compared with standard care (mean, 61.2 vs 54.2; = .0412).
In patients undergoing unilateral shoulder surgery, the use of cryotherapy with pneumatic compression, when compared with standard care, resulted in significantly decreased opioid consumption as well as increased function at 2 weeks.
NCT04185064 (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier).
肩部手术后的疼痛管理通常包括使用冷冻疗法和开阿片类镇痛药。最近,人们对阿片类药物泛滥问题给予了大量关注,而阿片类药物的过度处方是导致这一问题的部分原因。先前的研究发现,冷冻疗法和压缩联合使用可有效减少膝关节和脊柱手术后患者的镇痛药物消耗,并促进其康复;然而,这种方法在肩部手术后的疗效尚未得到评估。
评估与标准冷冻治疗相比,冷冻气动压缩设备在减少术后肩部疼痛、减少阿片类药物使用和提高生活质量方面的效果。
随机对照试验;证据水平,2 级。
共纳入 200 名年龄大于 18 岁、计划行单侧肩部手术的患者。患者被随机分配接受术后冷冻气动压缩或标准护理。干预组接受冷冻气动设备治疗,而标准护理组接受手术医生首选的术后护理方法,包括标准冷冻治疗。通过术后口服吗啡等效物的数量以及停止使用阿片类药物的时间来评估阿片类药物的使用情况。患者报告的结果测量包括数字评分量表疼痛评分、36 项简短健康调查、使用净推荐值评估的患者体验以及不良事件。术后 2、6 和 12 周进行评估。
与标准护理相比,接受冷冻气动压缩治疗的患者报告阿片类药物消耗显著减少(口服吗啡等效物中位数,56.1 比 112; =.02468)。与标准护理相比,冷冻气动压缩组在 2 周时自我报告的功能显著增加(平均,61.2 比 54.2; =.0412)。
在接受单侧肩部手术的患者中,与标准护理相比,使用冷冻气动压缩治疗可显著减少阿片类药物消耗,并在 2 周时提高功能。
NCT04185064(ClinicalTrials.gov 标识符)。