Does the PedsQL reflect the real-time quality of life in autistic adolescents? A comparison with the experience sampling methodology.

BACKGROUND

The PedsQL is widely used to retrospectively evaluate quality of life (QoL) in autistic adolescents. However, concerns have arisen regarding its ability to reflect real-time QoL, considering their challenges in recollecting past experiences.

OBJECTIVE

We examined the overall and social QoLs of autistic adolescents compared to neurotypical peers using the PedsQL and the experience sampling method (ESM), an ecological momentary assessment of QoL in real-time. Additionally, we explored the relationship between these measures in each group.

METHODS

A total of 175 participants, including 117 autistic and 58 neurotypical adolescents aged 10-16, completed the PedsQL and an ESM protocol with a mobile device to record their real-time experiences seven times a day for seven days. We performed multiple linear regression and multilevel analyses to compare QoLs between groups and the association between the two measures.

RESULTS

Autistic adolescents scored significantly lower than neurotypical peers on PedsQL overall and social QoL but not on the real-time experiences collected with ESM. Among neurotypical adolescents, we found significant associations between the Social Functioning score of the PedsQL and various aspects of real-time social experiences recorded with ESM. For autistic adolescents, only the real-time experience of 'loneliness' during social engagement was associated with Social Functioning on the PedsQL.

CONCLUSIONS

The retrospective PedsQL does not entirely capture the real-time QoL via ESM. However, relying solely on ESM may overlook situations where participants opt out or could not complete surveys. Thus, using both retrospective and real-time assessments to examine QoL among autistic adolescents is recommended.