Clifton G L, Robertson C S, Contant C F
J Neurosurg. 1985 Feb;62(2):186-93. doi: 10.3171/jns.1985.62.2.0186.
The objectives of this study were to determine the ability of enteral hyperalimentation to meet the caloric and protein requirements in acute severe head injury, and to study the effect of increasing protein intake on nitrogen balance. This consecutive series of 20 patients suffered acute severe head injury and remained comatose for at least 24 hours. They were all without other major injuries, and were treated with steroids. These patients were randomly placed in two comparable treatment groups: one group was fed with an enteral formula containing 14% of its calories as protein and the other group received a formula containing 22% protein calories. Feedings were advanced to replace 140% of caloric expenditure measured by indirect calorimetry, averaging 3500 kcal/24 hr. Balance periods of the targeted intake were 7 days in duration, and were begun during the 1st week after injury for 65% of patients and in the 2nd week after injury for 35% of patients. The lower protein group received an average of 26.8 gm/24 hr of nitrogen, equivalent to 188 gm of protein, and the higher protein group 34.3 gm/24 hr, equivalent to 231 gm of protein. Nitrogen balance was -9.2 +/- 6.7 gm/24 hr in the lower protein group and -5.3 +/- 5.0 gm/24 hr in the higher protein group, but the difference did not reach statistical significance because of sample size and variability in extent of catabolism among patients. Despite the hyperalimentation, there was a mean negative cumulative nitrogen balance of 200 gm by the 2nd week after injury, and only three patients achieved net nitrogen equilibrium for the 7-day balance period. Despite enteral hyperalimentation, the patients' weight fell by 15% in the 2nd week, serum albumin was often decreased, and creatinine-height index decreased over time but remained in a normal range. Monitoring urinary urea nitrogen, which has been advocated as a generally available technique for measuring urinary nitrogen concentration, was found to be a poor measure of urinary nitrogen excretion. This work has demonstrated: 1) that high caloric and protein feedings may be delivered for prolonged periods enterally for most patients in the acute phase of head injury with few metabolic complications, and 2) that increasing the nitrogen content of feedings from 14% to 22% may somewhat improve nitrogen retention, although nitrogen equilibrium is seldom achieved.
本研究的目的是确定肠内高营养能否满足急性重型颅脑损伤患者的热量和蛋白质需求,并研究增加蛋白质摄入量对氮平衡的影响。这一连续系列的20例患者均遭受急性重型颅脑损伤,且昏迷至少24小时。他们均无其他严重损伤,并接受了类固醇治疗。这些患者被随机分为两个可比的治疗组:一组喂食含14%热量为蛋白质的肠内配方奶,另一组接受含22%蛋白质热量的配方奶。喂食量逐渐增加,以补充通过间接测热法测得的热量消耗的140%,平均为3500千卡/24小时。目标摄入量的平衡期为7天,65%的患者在受伤后第1周开始,35%的患者在受伤后第2周开始。低蛋白组平均每24小时摄入26.8克氮,相当于188克蛋白质,高蛋白组为34.3克/24小时,相当于231克蛋白质。低蛋白组的氮平衡为-9.2±6.7克/24小时,高蛋白组为-5.3±5.0克/24小时,但由于样本量和患者分解代谢程度的变异性,差异未达到统计学意义。尽管进行了高营养治疗,但受伤后第2周时平均累积氮平衡仍为负200克,只有3例患者在7天平衡期内实现了净氮平衡。尽管进行了肠内高营养治疗,但患者体重在第2周下降了15%,血清白蛋白经常降低,肌酐身高指数随时间下降但仍在正常范围内。监测尿尿素氮(一直被倡导作为一种普遍可用的测量尿氮浓度的技术)被发现是一种较差的尿氮排泄测量方法。这项研究表明:1)对于大多数处于颅脑损伤急性期的患者,高热量和高蛋白喂食可以通过肠内长时间进行,且几乎没有代谢并发症;2)将喂食中的氮含量从14%提高到22%可能会在一定程度上改善氮潴留,尽管很少能实现氮平衡。