Brians 1 Prison Centre, Sant Esteve Sesrovires, Spain and Manresa Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Vic - Central University of Catalonia, Manresa, Spain.
Sant Esteve Sesrovires Prison Primary Care Team (Brians 1 Prison Centre), South Metropolitan Primary Health Care, Catalan Health Institute, Barcelona, Spain and Jordi Gol i Gurina Foundation Institute for Primary Health Care, Research (IDIAP JGol), Barcelona, Spain.
Int J Prison Health (2024). 2024 Aug 27;20(3):313-326. doi: 10.1108/IJOPH-05-2023-0028.
This study aims to learn about the experiences of inmates who experienced long periods of isolation due to a COVID-19 outbreak in the Brians 1 penitentiary centre. This approach is relevant, as it sought to understand the experiences from the perspective of the prisoners during periods of isolation. The aim was to gain in-depth knowledge, based on the idiosyncrasies of this population, of their emotions and coping strategies in the prison context. This information that may be useful to prison institutions and prison primary healthcare teams to guide the organisation in future health emergencies involving the isolation of prisoners.
DESIGN/METHODOLOGY/APPROACH: A qualitative interpretative phenomenological study was conducted. Face-to-face semi-structured interviews were conducted with a sample of 30 people who had undergone a period of isolation due to a COVID-19 outbreak in one or two of the last two outbreaks at the Brians 1 (Barcelona) prison in 2022, in the days following periods of social isolation. The interviews were transcribed and analysed using the content analysis approach, and were coded using the NVivo 12 qualitative software. The credibility and validity of the data analysed were increased through triangulation at different levels. In this study, data was collected from a heterogeneous sample of prisoners, capturing different views among the prison population.
This research gave us the opportunity to collect prisoners' accounts of isolation due to COVID-19, in which it became clear that it conditioned the management of time and space in daily prison life. The restrictions amplified negative emotions such as anxiety, stress and restlessness and led to disruptions in communication with the outside world, daily prison activities and judicial processes. Despite these changes, the prisoners understood the imperatives of isolation and the need to adapt to the new situation for a limited period of time. Faced with the detrimental effect on their well-being, the prisoners employed coping strategies focused on emotional management, social supports and occupational engagement.
RESEARCH LIMITATIONS/IMPLICATIONS: This study is subject to several limitations related to the characteristics of the sample. No women participated in the study as the modules studied were exclusively for men. People with impaired cognitive abilities, were not included. With regard to the method, it is understood that conducting the interviews in the days after the isolation may have influenced the content and enthusiasm of the participants. Despite these limitations, we are confident that the data triangulation may have given us reliable insight that will further our knowledge of prisoners' experiences in this type of situation.
ORIGINALITY/VALUE: The issue of the negative impact of restrictive measures in the prison environment has rarely been studied from the perspective of prisoners. To the best of the authors' knowledge, this study is the first to provide qualitative data on the experiences of prisoners during periods of social isolation due to COVID-19 outbreaks in prisons in Catalonia (Spain). The narratives allowed the authors to determine what impact the restrictions had on the emotional well-being and daily life of the prison population, information that can help prison institutions and healthcare teams understand how prisoners experienced this type of situation. The authors were also able to carry out an in-depth study of the coping strategies used by the prisoners to deal with negative emotions during the COVID-19 outbreaks, which may serve to guide the organisation of material and human resources in future emergencies or regimented situations involving social isolation.
本研究旨在了解因布赖恩斯 1 监狱中心 COVID-19 爆发而长期隔离的囚犯的经历。这种方法是相关的,因为它试图从囚犯的角度理解隔离期间的体验。目的是根据该人群的特殊性,深入了解他们在监狱环境中的情绪和应对策略。这些信息可能对监狱机构和监狱初级保健团队有用,以指导他们在未来涉及囚犯隔离的卫生紧急情况中进行组织。
设计/方法/方法:进行了定性解释现象学研究。在 2022 年布赖恩斯 1 监狱(巴塞罗那)的最后两次爆发之一或两次爆发后,对因 COVID-19 爆发而在隔离期间经历过隔离的 30 人进行了面对面的半结构化访谈,在社会隔离后的几天。采访内容被转录并使用内容分析方法进行分析,并使用 NVivo 12 定性软件进行编码。通过不同层面的三角测量,增加了分析数据的可信度和有效性。在这项研究中,从囚犯的异质样本中收集了数据,捕捉了监狱人口中的不同观点。
这项研究使我们有机会收集囚犯因 COVID-19 而被隔离的情况,从中清楚地看出,这影响了监狱日常生活中时间和空间的管理。限制加剧了焦虑、压力和不安等负面情绪,并导致与外界的沟通、日常监狱活动和司法程序中断。尽管发生了这些变化,囚犯们还是理解了隔离的必要性,并需要在有限的时间内适应新情况。面对对他们福祉的不利影响,囚犯们采用了专注于情绪管理、社会支持和职业参与的应对策略。
研究局限性/影响:本研究受到与样本特征相关的几个限制。由于研究模块仅适用于男性,因此没有女性参与研究。没有包括认知能力受损的人。就方法而言,人们理解在隔离后几天进行访谈可能会影响参与者的内容和积极性。尽管存在这些限制,但我们相信数据三角测量可能为我们提供了可靠的见解,这将进一步加深我们对囚犯在这种情况下的体验的了解。
原创性/价值:从囚犯的角度研究监狱环境中限制措施的负面影响很少有研究。据作者所知,这是首次在加泰罗尼亚(西班牙)的监狱中提供关于囚犯在 COVID-19 爆发期间因社会隔离而经历的定性数据。这些叙述使作者能够确定限制措施对监狱人口的情绪健康和日常生活产生了什么影响,这些信息可以帮助监狱机构和医疗保健团队了解囚犯是如何经历这种情况的。作者还能够对囚犯在 COVID-19 爆发期间使用的应对策略进行深入研究,以应对负面情绪,这可能有助于指导未来涉及社会隔离的紧急情况或严格情况下的物资和人力资源组织。