Lu Hsin-Hui, Che Wei-Chun, Yang Yung-Hao, Tsao Feng-Ming
Division of Clinical Psychology, Graduate Institute of Behavioral Sciences, College of Medicine, Chang Gung University, Taoyuan, Taiwan.
Department of Child Psychiatry, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital at Linkou, Taoyuan, Taiwan.
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2024 Nov-Dec;59(6):2671-2685. doi: 10.1111/1460-6984.13107. Epub 2024 Aug 27.
This longitudinal study investigated the language skills, phonological working memory and lexical-tone perception of Mandarin-speaking late-talkers (LTs) and those with typical language development (TLD) at 27 months, while also examining their connections with novel word-referent mapping (W-R mapping) through eye-tracking at 33 months.
Participants included 22 Mandarin-speaking 27-month-old LTs and 22 toddlers with TLD. Data on expressive and receptive language abilities, as well as phonological working memory and lexical-tone perception, were collected when participants were 27 months old. An eye-tracking paradigm was further employed during the word-learning tasks, which included W-R mapping and word-identification test (W-I test) phases at 33 months. Multilevel models were used to analyse participants' gaze pattern trajectories.
At 27 months, LT toddlers exhibited poorer language skills (receptive: p = 0.015, expressive: p < 0.001), lexical-tone perception (p < 0.001) and phonological working memory (p < 0.001) compared to those with TLD, even after considering maternal educational level and participants' fine motor ability. During the W-I test phase, we observed that LT toddlers showed a slower increase in fixations on the novel target image while listening to the corresponding novel word over time, compared to TLD toddlers (linear: p = 0.011, quadratic: p = 0.007) after adding confounders. Further, expressive language ability at 27 months old was a predictor of their newly established W-R mappings at 33 months old (p = 0.016). Additionally, the toddler's phonological working memory and lexical-tone perception were associated with their expressive language ability (p = 0.001 and < 0.001).
These findings indicate that the novel W-R mapping is not as robust in LTs as in TLDs, and the skills necessary for word learning share similarities with a wide range of expressive language abilities. Moreover, poor expressive language abilities were associated with deficits in lexical processing abilities; that is, phonological working memory and lexical-tone perception. These findings suggest the need for interventions aimed at improving LTs' lexical processing abilities to strengthen their lagging word-learning skills at toddlerhood.
What is already known on this subject Late-talkers (LTs) exhibit delays in expressive vocabulary development. Furthermore, they also perform poorly in word learning. What this paper adds to existing knowledge The eye-tracking paradigm was employed and found that novel word-referent mapping (W-R mapping) is not as robust in LTs as in those with typical language development. Toddlers' early expressive language ability could predict their ability to establish novel W-R mappings. Furthermore, the better the phonological working memory and lexical-tone perception of LTs are, the better their early expressive language ability is. What are the clinical implications of this work? Interventions might consider incorporating strategies to improve phonological working memory and lexical-tone perception to help Mandarin-speaking LTs enhance linguistic capacities and build robust novel W-R mapping.
这项纵向研究调查了27个月大的说普通话的说话晚儿童(LTs)和语言发育正常(TLD)儿童的语言技能、语音工作记忆和词汇声调感知,同时还通过33个月时的眼动追踪研究了它们与新的单词-指称映射(W-R映射)之间的联系。
参与者包括22名27个月大的说普通话的LTs儿童和22名TLD幼儿。在参与者27个月大时收集了表达性和接受性语言能力、语音工作记忆和词汇声调感知的数据。在单词学习任务中进一步采用了眼动追踪范式,该任务在33个月时包括W-R映射和单词识别测试(W-I测试)阶段。使用多层模型分析参与者的注视模式轨迹。
在27个月时,即使考虑了母亲的教育水平和参与者的精细运动能力,LT幼儿在语言技能(接受性:p = 0.015,表达性:p < 0.001)、词汇声调感知(p < 0.001)和语音工作记忆(p < 0.001)方面仍比TLD幼儿差。在W-I测试阶段,我们观察到,在加入混杂因素后,与TLD幼儿相比,LT幼儿在听相应新单词时,对新目标图像的注视增加速度较慢(线性:p = 0.011,二次:p = 0.007)。此外,27个月大时的表达性语言能力是其33个月大时新建立的W-R映射的一个预测指标(p = 0.016)。此外,幼儿的语音工作记忆和词汇声调感知与他们的表达性语言能力相关(p = 0.001和< 0.001)。
这些发现表明,新的W-R映射在LTs中不如在TLDs中稳固,单词学习所需的技能与广泛的表达性语言能力有相似之处。此外,表达性语言能力差与词汇处理能力缺陷有关;即语音工作记忆和词汇声调感知。这些发现表明需要进行干预,以提高LTs的词汇处理能力,从而加强他们在幼儿期滞后的单词学习技能。
关于该主题已知的信息 说话晚儿童(LTs)在表达性词汇发展方面存在延迟。此外,他们在单词学习方面也表现不佳。本文对现有知识的补充 采用了眼动追踪范式,发现新的单词-指称映射(W-R映射)在LTs中不如在语言发育正常的儿童中稳固。幼儿早期的表达性语言能力可以预测他们建立新的W-R映射的能力。此外,LTs的语音工作记忆和词汇声调感知越好,他们早期的表达性语言能力就越好。这项工作的临床意义是什么?干预措施可能需要考虑纳入改善语音工作记忆和词汇声调感知的策略,以帮助说普通话 的LTs提高语言能力并建立稳固的新W-R映射。