Al-Khouja Fares, Grigorian Areg, Emigh Brent, Schellenberg Morgan, Diaz Graal, Duncan Thomas K, Tuli Rahul, Coimbra Raul, Gilbert-Gard Kacy, Johnson Arianne, Marty Makenna, Jebbia Mallory, Obaid-Schmid Amal K, Fierro Nicole, Ley Eric, Bayat Dunya, Biffl Walter, Ebrahimian Shayan, Tillou M Areti, Tay-Lasso Erica, Alvarez Claudia, Nahmias Jeffry
Department of Surgery, University of California, Irvine (UCI), Orange, CA, USA.
Department of Surgery, Los Angeles County/University of Southern California Medical Center, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Am Surg. 2025 Jan;91(1):126-132. doi: 10.1177/00031348241278904. Epub 2024 Aug 27.
Current guidelines recommend 24-hour telemetry monitoring for isolated sternal fractures (ISFs) with electrocardiogram (ECG) abnormalities or troponin elevation. However, a single-center study suggested ISF patients with minor ECG abnormalities (sinus tachycardia/bradycardia, nonspecific arrhythmia/ST-changes, and bundle branch block) may not require 24-hour telemetry monitoring. This study sought to corroborate this, hypothesizing ISF patients would not develop blunt cardiac injury (BCI).
MATERIALS & METHODS: A retrospective study was performed at 8 trauma centers (1/2018-8/2020). Patients with ISF (abbreviated injury scale <2 for the head/neck/face/abdomen/extremities) and minor ECG abnormalities or troponin elevations were included. Patients with multiple rib fractures or hemothorax/pneumothorax were excluded. The primary outcome was an echocardiogram confirmed BCI. The secondary outcome was significant BCI defined as cardiogenic shock, dysrhythmia requiring treatment, post-traumatic cardiac structural defects, unexplained hypotension, or cardiac-related procedures. Descriptive statistics were performed.
Of 124 ISF patients with minor ECG abnormalities or troponin elevation, 90% were admitted with a mean stay of 35 hours. Echocardiogram was performed for 31.5% of patients, 10 (25.6%) of which had abnormalities. However, no patient had BCI diagnosed on echocardiography. In total, 2 patients (1.6%) had a significant BCI (atrial fibrillation and supraventricular tachycardia at 10 and 82 hours after injury). No patient died.
Following ISF with minor ECG changes or troponin elevation, <2% suffered significant BCI, and none had an echocardiogram diagnosed BCI, despite >30% receiving echocardiogram. These findings challenge the dogma of mandatory observation periods following ISF with associated ECG abnormalities and support the lack of utility for routine echocardiography in these patients.
当前指南建议,对于伴有心电图(ECG)异常或肌钙蛋白升高的孤立性胸骨骨折(ISF)患者,应进行24小时遥测监测。然而,一项单中心研究表明,心电图轻度异常(窦性心动过速/过缓、非特异性心律失常/ST段改变以及束支传导阻滞)的ISF患者可能不需要24小时遥测监测。本研究旨在证实这一点,假设ISF患者不会发生钝性心脏损伤(BCI)。
在8个创伤中心进行了一项回顾性研究(2018年1月至2020年8月)。纳入ISF患者(头部/颈部/面部/腹部/四肢的简明损伤分级<2)且伴有轻度心电图异常或肌钙蛋白升高。排除多根肋骨骨折或血胸/气胸患者。主要结局是超声心动图确诊的BCI。次要结局是严重BCI,定义为心源性休克、需要治疗的心律失常、创伤后心脏结构缺陷、不明原因的低血压或心脏相关手术。进行了描述性统计。
124例伴有轻度心电图异常或肌钙蛋白升高的ISF患者中,90%入院,平均住院时间为35小时。31.5%的患者进行了超声心动图检查,其中10例(25.6%)有异常。然而,超声心动图检查未诊断出任何患者有BCI。共有2例患者(1.6%)发生严重BCI(分别在受伤后10小时和82小时出现心房颤动和室上性心动过速)。无患者死亡。
ISF伴有轻度心电图改变或肌钙蛋白升高后,<2%的患者发生严重BCI,尽管>30%的患者接受了超声心动图检查,但无一例经超声心动图诊断为BCI。这些发现挑战了ISF伴有相关心电图异常后强制观察期的教条,并支持在这些患者中常规超声心动图检查无用的观点。