Pebole Michelle M, Iverson Katherine M, Bolduc Caitlin M, Joyce Julie M, Sablone Caroline A, Fortier Catherine B
The Translational Research Center for TBI and Stress Disorders (TRACTS), VA Boston Healthcare System, Jamaica Plain, Boston, MA 02130, USA.
Department of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA 02215, USA.
Brain Sci. 2024 Aug 14;14(8):814. doi: 10.3390/brainsci14080814.
Women veterans (WVs) are more likely than men veterans to experience traumatic brain injury (TBI) from causes unrelated to deployment. Yet, current Veterans Health Administration (VHA) TBI screening focuses on deployment. This study examines the utility of the VHA TBI screening tool for WVs. Using the Boston Assessment for TBI-Lifetime (BAT-L) as the gold standard, sensitivity and specificity of the VHA screen were identified for deployment and non-deployment injuries. Injuries missed by the screen were thematically described. Sensitivity and specificity were compared by context (research, clinical). Ninety WVs were included; fifty-three (60.9%) met TBI criteria per the BAT-L. For TBIs occurring during deployment, sensitivity was higher in research (89.1%) compared to clinics (61.7%); specificity was lower in research (60.7%) compared to clinics (93.0%). The BAT-L identified 27 non-deployment TBIs not captured by the VHA screen, most frequently from physical assault or sports. The VHA screen does not include non-deployment events; thus, non-deployment sensitivity and specificity could not be calculated. For lifetime TBIs (deployment + non-deployment etiologies), sensitivity was higher in research (73.5%) compared to clinics (48.9%). Specificity was lower in research (60.0%) compared to clinics (100.0%). Findings can inform improvements to TBI screening among WVs, including expansion for interpersonal violence.
女性退伍军人比男性退伍军人更有可能因与部署无关的原因而遭受创伤性脑损伤(TBI)。然而,目前退伍军人健康管理局(VHA)的TBI筛查重点是部署情况。本研究探讨了VHA的TBI筛查工具对女性退伍军人的实用性。以波士顿创伤性脑损伤终身评估(BAT-L)作为金标准,确定了VHA筛查对部署相关损伤和非部署相关损伤的敏感性和特异性。对筛查遗漏的损伤进行了主题描述。按背景(研究、临床)比较了敏感性和特异性。纳入了90名女性退伍军人;根据BAT-L,53名(60.9%)符合TBI标准。对于部署期间发生的TBI,研究中的敏感性(89.1%)高于临床(61.7%);研究中的特异性(60.7%)低于临床(93.0%)。BAT-L识别出27例VHA筛查未发现的非部署相关TBI,最常见于身体攻击或运动。VHA筛查不包括非部署事件;因此,无法计算非部署的敏感性和特异性。对于终身TBI(部署+非部署病因),研究中的敏感性(73.5%)高于临床(48.9%)。研究中的特异性(60.0%)低于临床(100.0%)。研究结果可为改善女性退伍军人的TBI筛查提供参考,包括扩大人际暴力方面的筛查。