Laboratory of Experimental Cardiology, University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Department of Cardiology, Amsterdam Cardiovascular Sciences, Amsterdam UMC, Heart Centre, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Ann Noninvasive Electrocardiol. 2024 Sep;29(5):e70003. doi: 10.1111/anec.70003.
Coronary vascular dysfunction comprises VSA and/or MVA and is more common in women than in men with angina without obstructive coronary artery disease (ANOCA). Invasive coronary function testing is considered the reference test for diagnosis, but its burden on patients is large. We aimed to investigate the potential of electrocardiography (ECG) as noninvasive marker for vasospastic angina (VSA) and microvascular angina (MVA) diagnosis.
We systematically screened Pubmed and EMBASE databases for studies reporting on ECG characteristics in ANOCA patients with (a suspicion of) coronary vascular dysfunction. We assessed study quality using QUADAS-2. We extracted data on diagnostic values of different ECG characteristics and analyzed whether the studies were sex-stratified.
Thirty publications met our criteria, 13 reported on VSA and 17 on MVA. The majority addressed repolarization-related ECG parameters. Only 1 of the 13 VSA papers and 4 of the 17 MVA papers showed diagnostic accuracy measures of the ECG characteristics. The presence of early repolarization, T-wave alternans, and inverted U waves showed of predictive value for VSA diagnosis. The QTc interval was predictive for MVA diagnosis in all six studies reporting on QTc interval. Sex-stratified results were reported in only 5 of the 30 studies and 3 of those observed sex-based differences.
ECG features are not widely evaluated in diagnostic studies for VSA and MVA. Those features predictive for VSA and MVA diagnosis mostly point to repolarization abnormalities and may contribute to noninvasive risk stratification.
冠状动脉血管功能障碍包括血管痉挛性心绞痛(VSA)和/或微血管性心绞痛(MVA),在无阻塞性冠状动脉疾病(ANOCA)的心绞痛女性患者中比男性更为常见。血管内冠状动脉功能测试被认为是诊断的参考测试,但对患者的负担很大。我们旨在研究心电图(ECG)作为血管痉挛性心绞痛(VSA)和微血管性心绞痛(MVA)诊断的潜在非侵入性标志物。
我们系统地筛选了 Pubmed 和 EMBASE 数据库,以寻找报告 ANOCA 患者(疑似)存在冠状动脉血管功能障碍时心电图特征的研究。我们使用 QUADAS-2 评估研究质量。我们提取了不同心电图特征的诊断价值数据,并分析了研究是否进行了性别分层。
符合标准的有 30 篇文献,其中 13 篇报告了 VSA,17 篇报告了 MVA。大多数研究涉及复极相关的心电图参数。在 13 篇 VSA 论文中,只有 1 篇,在 17 篇 MVA 论文中,有 4 篇显示了心电图特征的诊断准确性测量。早期复极、T 波交替和倒置 U 波的存在对 VSA 诊断具有预测价值。在报告 QTc 间期的 6 项研究中,QTc 间期对 MVA 诊断具有预测价值。在 30 项研究中,只有 5 项研究报告了性别分层结果,其中 3 项观察到了性别差异。
心电图特征在 VSA 和 MVA 的诊断研究中并未得到广泛评估。那些对 VSA 和 MVA 诊断具有预测价值的特征大多指向复极异常,可能有助于非侵入性风险分层。