Department of Intensive Care, Westmead Hospital, Westmead, Australia.
Department of Intensive Care, Gosford Hospital, Gosford, Australia.
Anaesth Intensive Care. 2024 Sep;52(5):314-320. doi: 10.1177/0310057X241257529. Epub 2024 Aug 30.
Routine chest X-ray (CXR) post intrathoracic drain removal in cardiac surgical patients is common practice to identify the presence of a pneumothorax following drain removal. Such pneumothoraces occur infrequently and rarely require intervention. We investigated the utility of routine CXR post drain removal and hypothesised that the practice is unnecessary and a possible area for significant cost saving. We conducted a single-centre, retrospective study of 390 patients who underwent cardiac surgery over a one-year period. Routine CXR post drain removal was reviewed for the presence of a pneumothorax. Rates of intervention post routine CXR were analysed to assess for clinical benefit obtained from this practice. Potential cost savings were calculated by the cost of a mobile CXR and by considering the radiographer's time. There were 15 pneumothoraces detected on routine CXR post drain removal. All pneumothoraces detected on routine post drain removal CXR were defined as small. No patients had a clinically significant pneumothorax requiring re-insertion of a chest drain. The potential cost saved by omitting routine CXR post drain removal was estimated to be approximately A$7750 per year. This study did not detect any clinically significant pneumothoraces requiring intervention. It also suggests that routine CXR post drain removal does not provide any clinical benefit and indicates that current practice should be reviewed.
在心胸外科手术后,常规进行胸部 X 光(CXR)检查以确定在胸腔引流管移除后是否存在气胸,这是一种常见做法。这种气胸很少见,很少需要干预。我们研究了常规 CXR 检查在引流管移除后的应用价值,并假设这种做法是不必要的,并且可能存在显著的节省成本的空间。
我们进行了一项单中心、回顾性研究,纳入了在一年内接受心脏手术的 390 名患者。我们对引流管移除后常规进行 CXR 检查的结果进行了评估,以确定这种做法是否能获得临床益处。通过计算移动 CXR 的成本和考虑放射技师的时间,我们计算了潜在的成本节约。
在引流管移除后常规 CXR 检查中发现了 15 例气胸。所有在引流管移除后常规 CXR 检查中发现的气胸均被定义为小量气胸。没有患者出现需要重新插入胸腔引流管的临床显著气胸。通过省略引流管移除后常规 CXR 检查,预计每年可节省约 7750 澳元。
本研究未发现任何需要干预的临床显著气胸。这也表明引流管移除后常规 CXR 检查不能提供任何临床益处,并表明目前的做法应进行审查。