Université Paris-Dauphine, PSL Research University, CNRS, IRD, LEDa, France.
Université Paris-Dauphine, PSL Research University, CNRS, IRD, LEDa, France; Institut de Recherche et de Documentation en Economie de la Santé (IRDES), Paris, France.
Soc Sci Med. 2024 Oct;358:117194. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2024.117194. Epub 2024 Aug 6.
Promoting equity in healthcare use requires to respect both principles of horizontal equity, that guarantees everyone the same use of healthcare for a given level of need, and vertical equity, that requires the sickest to receive more care than others, in a proportion deemed appropriate. This study explores the extent to which horizontal and vertical equity in healthcare use among individuals aged 50+ in Europe has been restructured during the COVID-19 pandemic. Using the variance as an inequality measure, we assess horizontal equity in healthcare use based on the fairness gap approach and propose two new measures of vertical equity. The sample includes 24,965 respondents of the SHARE survey from 18 European countries, who participated in wave 8 just before the pandemic and the second SHARE Corona survey in 2021. These data provide information on use of physician and hospital care over the year for each period, as well as on a wide range of health and socio-economic variables. Although pro-rich inequities in healthcare use were observed in some countries before the outbreak, our results do not reveal any significant evolution in horizontal equity during the pandemic. Conversely, vertical equity in healthcare use would have significantly declined in most countries, especially in Central or Eastern Europe. Telemedicine appears to have played a protective role against this decline in vertical equity in countries where it was heavily used during the pandemic. Our results support the case for public policies aimed at restoring access to care for individuals with the highest needs.
促进医疗保健公平使用需要尊重横向公平原则,即保证每个人在同等需求水平下都能获得相同的医疗保健服务,也需要尊重纵向公平原则,即要求最需要的人获得比其他人更多的医疗保健服务,而这一比例被认为是适当的。本研究探讨了在 COVID-19 大流行期间,欧洲 50 岁以上人群的医疗保健公平使用在多大程度上发生了变化。我们使用方差作为不平等衡量标准,根据公平差距方法评估医疗保健公平使用的横向公平,并提出了两种新的垂直公平衡量标准。该样本包括来自 18 个欧洲国家的 24965 名 SHARE 调查受访者,他们在大流行前参加了第 8 波调查,以及 2021 年的 SHARE Corona 调查。这些数据提供了每个时期一年内医生和医院护理使用情况的信息,以及广泛的健康和社会经济变量。尽管在疫情爆发前一些国家已经观察到了医疗保健使用的有利于富人的不平等现象,但我们的研究结果并没有显示出在疫情期间横向公平有任何显著变化。相反,在大多数国家,尤其是在中欧或东欧国家,医疗保健使用的垂直公平性显著下降。在疫情期间大量使用远程医疗的国家,远程医疗似乎起到了保护作用,防止垂直公平性下降。我们的研究结果支持采取公共政策的理由,旨在为最需要的人恢复医疗保健服务。