Clark Rob, Kroska Amy
University of California-Riverside, United States.
University of California-Riverside, United States.
Soc Sci Res. 2024 Aug;122:103051. doi: 10.1016/j.ssresearch.2024.103051. Epub 2024 Jul 3.
Women are under-represented in political leadership roles, comprising only a quarter of national parliament members across the world. This is surprising, given women's comparatively high level of education and labor force participation. Why has women's political leadership lagged behind other indicators of gender equality? In this study, we revisit the importance of gender attitudes and examine the extent to which they shape women's share of parliament. Prior studies either examine gender attitudes by relying on cross-sectional research designs with small samples or adopt proxy measures that serve as crude indicators of gender ideology. We overcome these limitations by directly measuring gender attitudes from the World Values Survey and European Values Study, while adopting a panel design with a larger sample of countries and a more comprehensive set of controls. Drawing from our dataset of 275 observations across 101 countries during the 1995-2021 period, we find that our attitudinal measure, gender egalitarianism, wipes away most of the observed differences in women's share of parliament between world regions. Moreover, when we add two-way fixed effects, we find that a one-unit increase in a country's gender egalitarianism score is associated with an increase in women's parliament share by about four or five percentage points. Finally, we address concerns about endogeneity by replicating our results using two-stage least squares models with fixed effects. Overall, our findings suggest that gender ideology helps account for the growing success and persistent obstacles faced by women political candidates across the world.
女性在政治领导角色中的代表性不足,在全球各国议会议员中仅占四分之一。鉴于女性相对较高的教育水平和劳动力参与率,这一现象令人惊讶。为何女性的政治领导力落后于其他性别平等指标?在本研究中,我们重新审视性别态度的重要性,并考察其对女性在议会中所占比例的影响程度。先前的研究要么依靠小样本的横断面研究设计来考察性别态度,要么采用作为性别意识形态粗略指标的代理措施。我们通过直接测量《世界价值观调查》和《欧洲价值观研究》中的性别态度来克服这些局限性,同时采用涵盖更多国家样本和更全面控制变量的面板设计。根据我们在1995年至2021年期间对101个国家的275次观察数据集,我们发现,我们的态度衡量指标——性别平等主义,消除了世界各地区女性在议会中所占比例的大部分观察差异。此外,当我们加入双向固定效应时,我们发现一个国家的性别平等主义得分每提高一个单位,女性在议会中的比例就会增加约四到五个百分点。最后,我们通过使用固定效应的两阶段最小二乘法模型来复制我们的结果,以解决内生性问题。总体而言,我们的研究结果表明,性别意识形态有助于解释世界各地女性政治候选人取得的越来越大的成功以及持续面临的障碍。