Correlation between renal sonographic measurements and differential renal function obtained from nuclear renography in children with unilateral hydronephrosis.

INTRODUCTION

Children with higher grades of hydronephrosis often undergo mercaptoacetyltriglycine nuclear renography scans (MAG3) to assess differential renal function (DRF) and drainage. Although MAG3 helps identify the potential need for pyeloplasty, its use incurs increased costs, radiation exposure, and stress for children and families. Several studies demonstrate pyramidal thickness (PT) ≤ 3 mm as a reliable predictive risk factor for pyeloplasty in children with a history of prenatal hydronephrosis. Our hypothesis was that renal sonographic measurements including PT and parenchymal thickness (ParT) correlate with DRF in children with high-grade unilateral hydronephrosis and may be used to better select the need and frequency of MAG3 scans in children at increased risk for diminished relative renal function. The objective of this project was to determine the correlation between sonographic renal measurements and DRF in patients with unilateral hydronephrosis, we assessed: 1) the correlation between PT, ParT, and the ratio of PT/ParT in hydronephrotic kidneys to DRF, 2) the correlation between the ratio of hydronephrotic PT/contralateral non-hydronephrotic PT and DRF, 3) the correlation between the ratio of hydronephrotic ParT/contralateral non-hydronephrotic ParT and DRF, and 4) the correlation between the ratio of (hydronephrotic PT/ParT)/(contralateral non-hydronephrotic PT/ParT) and DRF.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed 71 children with grades 3 or 4 unilateral hydronephrosis. Most patients presented with a history of prenatally detected hydronephrosis at median age (IQR) of 112 days (43-274). Measurements of PT and ParT were completed on 98 renal ultrasounds and DRF was collected from corresponding MAG3 scans. Threshold values were identified visually through scatterplots. Spearman's correlation coefficient and Fisher's p-values were calculated.

DISCUSSION

Ratios of PT and ParT in hydronephrotic kidneys to contralateral non-hydronephrotic kidneys were positively correlated with DRF. Ratios of hydronephrotic PT/non-hydronephrotic PT > 0.8 and hydronephrotic ParT/non-hydronephrotic ParT >0.7 occurred more frequently in patients with a DRF >40% (p = 0.11 and p = 0.001, respectively). A PT > 3 mm and ParT >5 mm occurred significantly more frequently in patients with a DRF >40% (p = 0.008 and p = 0.006, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

Renal sonographic measurements including threshold values of PT > 3 mm, ParT > 5 mm, ratio of hydronephrotic PT/contralateral non-hydronephrotic PT (>0.8), and ratio of hydronephrotic ParT/contralateral non-hydronephrotic ParT (>0.7) are good predictors of DRF >40% in unilateral high-grade hydronephrosis. These identified threshold values have potential utility in determining the need for nuclear renal scans in children with high-grade hydronephrosis.