Faculté de médecine Lyon-Est, Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Lyon, France.
Université Laval, Québec, Canada.
BMC Med Educ. 2024 Sep 3;24(1):961. doi: 10.1186/s12909-024-05895-0.
Social accountability aims to promote a collective ethic that upholds the fundamental values of equity, efficiency, solidarity, and social justice in healthcare and is now considered as a critical mission of academic health centers. Collaborative Online International Learning (COIL) is a pedagogical approach that uses digital technology to provide experiential international learning, specifically for increasingly diverse and multicultural healthcare work environments. The SOLID'AIRS program is an innovative French-language COIL that aims to set up international exchanges and workshops on social accountability between health sciences students. The aim of our study was to assess the impact of participation in the SOLID'AIRS program on medical and pharmacy students.
Five universities in four different countries were involved in SOLID'AIRS. We conducted a qualitative study by performing individual, semi-directed interviews with students who participated in the program from 2021 to 2022. A thematic analysis was conducted in five chronological phases: (1) reading, (2) descriptive coding, (3) conceptual coding, (4) identification of themes and (5) production of a coherent thematic structure.
After including sixteen student participants, 13 medical and 3 pharmacy students, we identified four main themes related to the impact of participation: (1) previous experiences in social accountability and international learning, (2) perception of the program, (3) perceived impacts of the program, and (4) difficulties encountered and avenues to improve the program. Overall, the program was well received by all participants who reported the advantages and limitations of the online learning format. The primary advantage of this format was its feasibility. The participants noted both professional and personal benefits of the program for their current and future practice, including greater reflexivity towards health sciences practice. Based on the challenges faced during the program, particularly in coordinating group work and communication, participants suggested increased supervision of group projects by collaborators, and organizing at least one in-person meeting for future editions. The participants reported encountering difficulties during the COIL and suggested ways of improvement.
Participating in a COIL on social accountability appears to be an effective way to adopt a reflective approach to medical practice and should be implemented and evaluated in other educational contexts.
社会问责旨在促进一种集体道德,即在医疗保健中维护公平、效率、团结和社会正义等基本价值观,现在被认为是学术健康中心的一项重要使命。合作在线国际学习(COIL)是一种使用数字技术提供体验式国际学习的教学方法,特别是针对日益多样化和多元文化的医疗保健工作环境。SOLID'AIRS 计划是一种创新的法语 COIL,旨在为卫生科学学生之间的社会问责制建立国际交流和研讨会。我们的研究目的是评估参与 SOLID'AIRS 计划对医学生和药剂学生的影响。
四个国家的五所大学参与了 SOLID'AIRS。我们通过对 2021 年至 2022 年期间参与该计划的学生进行个人、半定向访谈进行了定性研究。采用主题分析法进行了五个时间顺序的阶段:(1)阅读,(2)描述性编码,(3)概念性编码,(4)主题识别和(5)连贯主题结构的生成。
在纳入 16 名学生参与者,13 名医学生和 3 名药剂学生后,我们确定了与参与相关的四个主要主题:(1)社会问责制和国际学习的先前经验,(2)对计划的看法,(3)计划的感知影响,以及(4)遇到的困难和改进计划的途径。总体而言,所有参与者都对该计划表示欢迎,他们报告了在线学习格式的优势和局限性。这种格式的主要优势是其可行性。参与者指出,该计划对他们当前和未来的实践都有专业和个人的好处,包括对健康科学实践的更大反思性。根据计划中面临的挑战,特别是在协调小组工作和沟通方面,参与者建议增加合作者对小组项目的监督,并为未来版本组织至少一次面对面会议。参与者报告在 COIL 期间遇到困难,并提出了改进方法。
参与社会问责制的 COIL 似乎是一种采用医学实践反思方法的有效途径,应该在其他教育环境中实施和评估。