Kumar Rajesh, Sheikh Nishat A, Vasudeva Abhimanyu, Kumar Adarsh, Yadav Abhishek, Gupta Sudhir K
Department of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Deoghar, Jharkhand, India.
Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Gorakhpur, Uttar Pradesh, India.
J Family Med Prim Care. 2024 Aug;13(8):3106-3110. doi: 10.4103/jfmpc.jfmpc_2055_22. Epub 2024 Jul 26.
The winter climate in Delhi is severe, with temperatures dropping below 10°C. As a result, individuals often resort to utilizing diverse heat sources such as electrical heating appliances, coal and gas geysers. Unfortunately, these sources are commonly associated with the emission of carbon monoxide (CO) which can accumulate in inadequately ventilated spaces. Exposure to this noxious gas can lead to acute lethargy and debilitation, leaving individuals in a state of helpless distress.
The present study utilized a retrospective descriptive analysis to examine cases of fatal carbon monoxide exposure retrieved from the Department of Forensic Medicine archives at the esteemed All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi. Autopsy records were thoroughly examined with respect to various parameters including age, gender, seasonality of the incident, circumstances surrounding the death, source of carbon monoxide generation, post mortem observations, as well as toxicological analysis reports.
This study entailed an analysis of 56 individuals who fell victim to carbon monoxide poisoning, with a staggering 95% of fatalities occurring during the winter season. The majority of the individuals affected belonged to the age bracket of 21-30 years. The most common sources of carbon monoxide exposure were linked to the use of coal-burning earthen or iron vessels for room heating, as well as structural fires. With the exception of one case, all incidents were accidental in nature. Additionally, nearly all of the victims were discovered in enclosed spaces with heating equipment in close proximity, and evidence of a struggle was noted on the crime scene or with the deceased.
The findings of this study indicate that the principal contributor to the inadvertent build-up of lethal concentrations of carbon monoxide gas is the utilization of heating appliances within inadequately ventilated, enclosed spaces. Due to the scentless and non-irritating properties of this gas, individuals who are asleep may be unable to detect its presence in their surroundings, thereby leading to a silent death. To mitigate such risks, the installation of carbon monoxide detectors is crucial. Additionally, it is of utmost importance to raise public awareness regarding the perils associated with using fire pots, coal burning and electrical heating appliances in areas with insufficient ventilation.
德里的冬季气候严寒,气温会降至10摄氏度以下。因此,人们常常借助各种热源,如电暖器、煤和燃气热水器。不幸的是,这些热源通常会排放一氧化碳(CO),而一氧化碳会在通风不良的空间中积聚。接触这种有害气体会导致急性嗜睡和身体虚弱,使人们陷入无助的困境。
本研究采用回顾性描述性分析,对从新德里著名的全印度医学科学研究所法医学系档案中检索到的一氧化碳中毒致死案例进行研究。对尸检记录进行了全面检查,涉及多个参数,包括年龄、性别、事件发生的季节、死亡周围的情况、一氧化碳产生的来源、尸检观察结果以及毒理学分析报告。
本研究对56名一氧化碳中毒受害者进行了分析,其中95%的死亡发生在冬季,令人震惊。受影响的大多数人年龄在21至30岁之间。一氧化碳暴露最常见的来源与使用烧煤的土制或铁制容器进行室内取暖以及建筑火灾有关。除了一个案例外,所有事件均为意外性质。此外,几乎所有受害者都是在靠近取暖设备的封闭空间中被发现的,并且在犯罪现场或死者身上发现了挣扎的迹象。
本研究结果表明,在通风不良的封闭空间内使用取暖设备是导致一氧化碳气体意外积聚至致命浓度的主要原因。由于这种气体无味且无刺激性,睡着的人可能无法察觉到周围环境中它的存在,从而导致无声死亡。为降低此类风险,安装一氧化碳探测器至关重要。此外,提高公众对在通风不足的区域使用火盆、烧煤和电暖器相关危险的认识也极为重要。