Department of Earth Sciences, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Department of Environmental Sciences, University of Toledo, Toledo, Ohio, USA.
J Forensic Sci. 2024 Nov;69(6):2054-2068. doi: 10.1111/1556-4029.15622. Epub 2024 Sep 4.
Studies assessing the use of ground-penetrating radar (GPR) for locating unmarked human graves commonly use pigs as proxies, with recent concerns about the adequacy of pigs as substitutes for humans. Also, there is little agreement on how to identify and describe GPR signals associated with graves. Hence, this project's aim is to compare GPR signals acquired over simulated clandestine graves with pig and human remains. We established human, pig, and control graves at the REST[ES] human decomposition facility in May 2022 and monitored the graves over 17 months using a 250 MHz antenna GPR system. Our results showed the presence of perturbed and V-shaped reflectors, diffraction hyperbolas, and reflectors with amplitude loss at depth between 0.6 and 0.75 m in the radargram for graves with human and pig remains. We corroborate recent studies which concluded that the use of proxies is a viable alternative to human cadavers. The observed radar signatures were classified into five key patterns, which are characteristic of similar data collected with 250 MHz above graves reported in the literature. These classes are: V-shaped dipping reflections from grave walls (class A), small hyperbolic reflections superimposed onto a near-linear reflector (class B), hyperbolic reflections from remains within the grave (class C), new high-amplitude reflection patterns (class D) and significant loss or interruption of reflections (class E). Our proposed classification can help streamline future investigations where the goal is to interpret burials within large GPR datasets and provide language to communicate these results to the broader scientific community.
研究评估使用探地雷达(GPR)定位未标记的人类坟墓通常使用猪作为替代品,但最近人们对猪作为人类替代品的充分性表示担忧。此外,对于如何识别和描述与坟墓相关的 GPR 信号,也没有达成共识。因此,本项目的目的是比较在模拟的秘密坟墓上获得的 GPR 信号与猪和人类遗骸。我们于 2022 年 5 月在 REST[ES]人类分解设施中建立了人类、猪和对照坟墓,并使用 250MHz 天线 GPR 系统在 17 个月内监测这些坟墓。我们的结果表明,在有人类和猪遗骸的坟墓的雷达图中,存在扰动和 V 形反射器、衍射双曲线以及在 0.6 至 0.75m 深度处具有幅度损失的反射器。我们证实了最近的研究结论,即使用替代品是替代人类尸体的可行方法。观察到的雷达特征被分为五个关键模式,这些模式与文献中报道的在 250MHz 以上坟墓上收集的类似数据的特征雷达特征一致。这些类别是:来自坟墓墙壁的 V 形倾斜反射(类别 A)、叠加在近线性反射器上的小双曲线反射(类别 B)、来自坟墓内遗骸的双曲线反射(类别 C)、新的高幅度反射模式(类别 D)和反射的显著损失或中断(类别 E)。我们提出的分类方法可以帮助简化未来的调查,目标是在大型 GPR 数据集内解释埋葬物,并为更广泛的科学界提供描述这些结果的语言。