Shner-Livne Gil, Barak Nadav, Shitrit Ido, Abend Rany, Shechner Tomer
School of Psychological Sciences and the Integrated Brain and Behavior Research Center, University of Haifa, Haifa, Israel.
Baruch Ivcher School of Psychology, Reichman University, Herzliya, Israel.
Psychol Med. 2024 Aug;54(11):3156-3167. doi: 10.1017/S0033291724001314. Epub 2024 Sep 6.
Major theories link threat learning processes to anxiety symptoms, which typically emerge during adolescence. While this developmental stage is marked by substantial maturation of the neural circuity involved in threat learning, research directly examining adolescence-specific patterns of neural responding during threat learning is scarce. This study compared adolescents and adults in acquisition and extinction of conditioned threat responses assessed at the cognitive, psychophysiological, and neural levels, focusing on the late positive potential (LPP), an event-related potential (ERP) component indexing emotional valence.
Sixty-five adults and 63 adolescents completed threat acquisition and extinction, 24 h apart, using the bell conditioning paradigm. Self-reported fear, skin conductance responses (SCR), and ERPs were measured.
Developmental differences emerged in neural and psychophysiological responses during threat acquisition, with adolescents displaying heightened LPP responses to threat and safety cues as well as heightened threat-specific SCR compared to adults. During extinction, SCR suggested comparable reduction in conditioned threat responses across groups, while LPP revealed incomplete extinction only among adolescents. Finally, age moderated the link between anxiety severity and LPP-assessed extinction, whereby greater anxiety severity was associated with reduced extinction among younger participants.
In line with developmental theories, adolescence is characterized by a specific age-related difficulty adapting to diminishing emotional significance of prior threats, contributing to heightened vulnerability to anxiety symptoms. Further, LPP appears to be sensitive to developmental differences in threat learning and may thus potentially serve as a useful biomarker in research on adolescents, threat learning, and anxiety.
主要理论将威胁学习过程与焦虑症状联系起来,焦虑症状通常在青春期出现。虽然这一发育阶段的特点是参与威胁学习的神经回路大量成熟,但直接研究威胁学习过程中特定于青春期的神经反应模式的研究却很少。本研究比较了青少年和成年人在认知、心理生理和神经水平上评估的条件性威胁反应的习得和消退情况,重点关注晚期正电位(LPP),这是一种与情绪效价相关的事件相关电位(ERP)成分。
65名成年人和63名青少年使用铃声条件反射范式,相隔24小时完成威胁习得和消退实验。测量自我报告的恐惧、皮肤电反应(SCR)和ERP。
在威胁习得过程中,神经和心理生理反应出现了发育差异,与成年人相比,青少年对威胁和安全线索表现出更高的LPP反应,以及更高的特定于威胁的SCR。在消退过程中,SCR表明各群体的条件性威胁反应有相当程度的降低,而LPP显示只有青少年存在消退不完全的情况。最后,年龄调节了焦虑严重程度与LPP评估的消退之间的联系,即焦虑严重程度越高,年轻参与者的消退程度越低。
与发育理论一致,青春期的特点是在适应先前威胁的情感重要性降低方面存在特定的与年龄相关的困难,这导致对焦虑症状的易感性增加。此外,LPP似乎对威胁学习中的发育差异敏感,因此可能潜在地作为研究青少年、威胁学习和焦虑的有用生物标志物。