Liu Xin-Yuan, Ma Yue, Huang Zong-Yue, Xiao Xin-Xin, Guan Ling
Department of Acupuncture and Moxibustion, Sixth Medical Center, Chinese People's Liberation Army General Hospital, Beijing,People's Republic of China.
Graduate School, Chinese People's Liberation Army Medical College, Beijing, People's Republic of China.
J Pain Res. 2024 Sep 2;17:2837-2849. doi: 10.2147/JPR.S465058. eCollection 2024.
To assess the effectiveness of acupuncture, exercise rehabilitation, and their combination in treating knee osteoarthritis (KOA).
This randomized controlled trial was done on patients with KOA, who were randomly allocated to three groups: acupuncture (AP), exercise rehabilitation (ER), or a combination of acupuncture and exercise rehabilitation (AE). The study lasted 12 weeks with 4 weeks of treatment and 8 weeks of follow-up. The primary outcome was the response rate, which was determined by the percentage of participants who experienced a significant improvement in pain and function by the fourth week. The primary analysis utilized a Z test for proportions in the modified intent-to-treat population, consisting of all randomized participants with at least one post-baseline measurement.
Out of the 120 patients initially enrolled in the study, 110 completed the trial and were included in the intention-to-treat analysis. Response rates at week 4 were 65.7% (23 out of 35), 58.3% (21 out of 36), and 83.3% (32 out of 39) in the AP, ER, and AE groups, respectively. The response rate in the AE group was found to be significantly higher than that in the ER group at week 4. No significant differences were observed in the overall response rates between the AP and ER groups, as well as between the AP and AE groups.
Our research indicates that both acupuncture and exercise rehabilitation can effectively enhance pain relief, functional improvement, and joint mobility in individuals aged 45 to 70 with moderate to severe chronic KOA. Furthermore, the AE group demonstrated the highest response rate. These beneficial outcomes were sustained for a minimum of 8 weeks post-treatment. The combination of acupuncture and exercise rehabilitation appears to enhance the overall therapeutic efficacy for KOA patients, suggesting a synergistic effect that may be particularly advantageous for those with moderate to severe symptoms.
评估针灸、运动康复及其联合应用治疗膝关节骨关节炎(KOA)的有效性。
本随机对照试验针对KOA患者进行,将其随机分为三组:针灸组(AP)、运动康复组(ER)或针灸与运动康复联合组(AE)。研究持续12周,其中治疗4周,随访8周。主要结局为缓解率,通过第4周时疼痛和功能有显著改善的参与者百分比来确定。主要分析采用Z检验,针对改良意向性治疗人群中的比例进行分析,该人群包括所有随机分组且至少有一次基线后测量值的参与者。
最初纳入研究的120例患者中,110例完成试验并纳入意向性治疗分析。AP组、ER组和AE组在第4周时的缓解率分别为65.7%(35例中的23例)、58.3%(36例中的21例)和83.3%(39例中的32例)。在第4周时,发现AE组的缓解率显著高于ER组。AP组与ER组之间以及AP组与AE组之间的总体缓解率未观察到显著差异。
我们的研究表明,针灸和运动康复均可有效提高45至70岁中度至重度慢性KOA患者的疼痛缓解、功能改善和关节活动度。此外,AE组的缓解率最高。这些有益结果在治疗后至少持续8周。针灸与运动康复联合应用似乎可提高KOA患者的总体治疗效果,提示存在协同效应,这可能对中度至重度症状患者特别有利。