Tong Zhiyue, An Fengcun, Cui Yanji
School of Foreign Languages, Yanbian University, Yanji, China.
Heliyon. 2024 Aug 17;10(16):e36435. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e36435. eCollection 2024 Aug 30.
Effective teacher discourse is critical in improving English as a foreign language (EFL) education, particularly in junior high schools in China, where students are at a crucial stage in their language development. As junior high school students are at a pivotal developmental stage, this research investigates the discourse patterns employed by novice and expert teachers to assess their impact on students' engagement and language acquisition. Despite the extensive research on teacher discourse in higher education, a significant gap remains regarding its application in compulsory primary education settings. This study aims to fill this gap by examining the current classroom discourse patterns of EFL teachers in junior high schools to identify the distinctions between novice and expert teachers and explore the factors contributing to these differences. This mixed-methods study includes qualitative and quantitative analyses. Verbatim transcriptions of six classes were used to create a corpus exceeding 20,000 words. The data were analysed using cross-tabulation in Excel and Chi-square tests in SPSS 22.0, complemented by semi-structured interviews with selected teachers. The theoretical framework is grounded in Long's(1996)interaction hypothesis, which underlines the significance of communication in facilitating language proficiency through meaningful interaction, and the analysis follows Sinclair and Coulthard's(1975)discourse patterns. The initiation-response-feedback (IRF) and initiation-response-0 (IR0) emerged as predominant patterns among both novice and expert teachers. Novice teachers predominantly relied on the basic IRF pattern, while expert teachers exhibited greater flexibility and more frequent use of variant patterns, such as IRFR, I[RF] and [IR]F. Such adaptability among expert teachers creates a more interactive and engaging learning environment, thereby enhancing student participation and language acquisition. The study also identifies a novel variant structure, IRF, used more frequently by expert teachers, underlining the benefits of group work in fostering teamwork and independent thinking. Expert teachers demonstrated a greater propensity to adapt their discourse strategies to foster a more production-oriented learning environment, which was the main factor driving the teachers' differing discourse patterns. This study significantly contributes to the analysis of teacher discourse in the junior high school EFL context, providing empirical evidence and practical insights that bridge the gap between theory and practice. By elucidating the distinct discourse practices of novice and expert teachers, this study offers valuable recommendations for teacher professional development and highlights the importance of employing varied and interactive discourse structures to improve EFL teaching effectiveness. The study also provides valuable insights for educators striving to improve their instructional practices and the language acquisition in EFL classrooms.
有效的教师话语对于提高外语(EFL)教育至关重要,在中国的初中尤其如此,因为学生正处于语言发展的关键阶段。由于初中生正处于关键的发展阶段,本研究调查新手教师和专家教师所采用的话语模式,以评估其对学生参与度和语言习得的影响。尽管对高等教育中的教师话语进行了广泛研究,但在义务小学教育环境中的应用仍存在重大差距。本研究旨在通过考察初中英语教师当前的课堂话语模式来填补这一差距,以识别新手教师和专家教师之间的差异,并探索造成这些差异的因素。这项混合方法研究包括定性和定量分析。六堂课的逐字记录被用于创建一个超过20000字的语料库。数据在Excel中使用交叉制表进行分析,并在SPSS 22.0中进行卡方检验,辅以对选定教师的半结构化访谈。理论框架基于朗(1996)的互动假设,该假设强调通过有意义的互动促进语言能力的交流的重要性,分析遵循辛克莱和库尔瑟德(1975)的话语模式。起始-回应-反馈(IRF)和起始-回应-0(IR0)在新手教师和专家教师中都是主要模式。新手教师主要依赖基本的IRF模式,而专家教师表现出更大的灵活性,更频繁地使用变体模式,如IRFR、I[RF]和[IR]F。专家教师的这种适应性创造了一个更具互动性和吸引力的学习环境,从而提高了学生的参与度和语言习得。该研究还识别出一种新的变体结构IRF,专家教师更频繁地使用它,强调了小组合作在培养团队合作和独立思考方面的好处。专家教师表现出更大的倾向,即调整他们的话语策略以营造一个更以产出为导向的学习环境,这是导致教师话语模式不同的主要因素。本研究对初中英语教学环境中的教师话语分析做出了重大贡献,提供了弥合理论与实践差距的实证证据和实际见解。通过阐明新手教师和专家教师不同的话语实践,本研究为教师专业发展提供了有价值的建议,并强调了采用多样化和互动性话语结构以提高英语教学效果的重要性。该研究还为努力改进教学实践和提高英语课堂语言习得的教育工作者提供了有价值的见解。