Department of Geography, University College London, London, UK.
Oxford Wildlife Trade Research Group, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, Oxford Brookes University, Oxford, UK.
Conserv Biol. 2024 Oct;38(5):e14341. doi: 10.1111/cobi.14341.
The surge in internet accessibility has transformed wildlife trade by facilitating the acquisition of wildlife through online platforms. This scenario presents unique ethical challenges for researchers, as traditional ethical frameworks for in-person research cannot be readily applied to the online realm. Currently, there is a lack of clearly defined guidelines for appropriate ethical procedures when conducting online wildlife trade (OWT) research. In response to this, we consulted the scientific literature on ethical considerations in online research and examined existing guidelines established by professional societies and ethical boards. Based on these documents, we present a set of recommendations that can inform the development of ethically responsible OWT research. Key ethical challenges in designing and executing OWT research include the violation of privacy rights, defining subjects and illegality, and the risk of misinterpretation or posing risks to participants when sharing data. Potential solutions include considering participants' expectations of privacy, defining when participants are authors versus subjects, understanding the legal and cultural context, minimizing data collection, ensuring anonymization, and removing metadata. Best practices also involve being culturally sensitive when analyzing and reporting findings. Adhering to these guidelines can help mitigate potential pitfalls and provides valuable insights to editors, researchers, and ethical review boards, enabling them to conduct scientifically rigorous and ethically responsible OWT research to advance this growing field.
互联网普及程度的提高使得通过在线平台获取野生动物变得更加便捷,从而改变了野生动物贸易的格局。这给研究人员带来了独特的伦理挑战,因为传统的实地研究伦理框架无法直接适用于网络领域。目前,在进行在线野生动物贸易(OWT)研究时,缺乏明确界定的适当伦理程序指南。有鉴于此,我们查阅了关于网络研究中伦理考虑的科学文献,并研究了专业协会和伦理委员会制定的现有准则。基于这些文件,我们提出了一系列建议,为制定负责任的 OWT 研究提供参考。在设计和执行 OWT 研究时,关键的伦理挑战包括侵犯隐私权利、确定主体和合法性问题,以及在分享数据时存在数据曲解或对参与者构成风险的风险。潜在的解决方案包括考虑参与者对隐私的期望,定义参与者是作者还是主体,了解法律和文化背景,最大限度地减少数据收集,确保匿名化,并删除元数据。最佳实践还包括在分析和报告研究结果时具有文化敏感性。遵守这些准则有助于减轻潜在的陷阱,并为编辑、研究人员和伦理审查委员会提供有价值的见解,使他们能够进行科学严谨和负责任的 OWT 研究,推动这一不断发展的领域取得进展。