Wei Zheng, Qu Huamin, Xu Xian
IEEE Trans Vis Comput Graph. 2025 Jan;31(1):962-972. doi: 10.1109/TVCG.2024.3456330. Epub 2024 Nov 25.
Data videos increasingly becoming a popular data storytelling form represented by visual and audio integration. In recent years, more and more researchers have explored many narrative structures for effective and attractive data storytelling. Meanwhile, the Hero's Journey provides a classic narrative framework specific to the Hero's story that has been adopted by various mediums. There are continuous discussions about applying Hero's Journey to data stories. However, so far, little systematic and practical guidance on how to create a data video for a specific story type like the Hero's Journey, as well as how to manipulate its sound and visual designs simultaneously. To fulfill this gap, we first identified 48 data videos aligned with the Hero's Journey as the common storytelling from 109 high-quality data videos. Then, we examined how existing practices apply Hero's Journey for creating data videos. We coded the 48 data videos in terms of the narrative stages, sound design, and visual design according to the Hero's Journey structure. Based on our findings, we proposed a design space to provide practical guidance on the narrative, visual, and sound custom design for different narrative segments of the hero's journey (i.e., Departure, Initiation, Return) through data video creation. To validate our proposed design space, we conducted a user study where 20 participants were invited to design data videos with and without our design space guidance, which was evaluated by two experts. Results show that our design space provides useful and practical guidance for data storytellers effectively creating data videos with the Hero's Journey.
数据视频正日益成为一种以视觉和音频整合为代表的流行数据叙事形式。近年来,越来越多的研究人员探索了许多用于有效且吸引人的数据叙事的叙事结构。与此同时,“英雄之旅”提供了一个特定于英雄故事的经典叙事框架,已被各种媒介所采用。关于将“英雄之旅”应用于数据故事的讨论不断。然而,到目前为止,对于如何为像“英雄之旅”这样的特定故事类型创建数据视频,以及如何同时操纵其声音和视觉设计,几乎没有系统且实用的指导。为了填补这一空白,我们首先从109个高质量数据视频中识别出48个与“英雄之旅”一致的作为常见叙事的数据视频。然后,我们研究了现有实践如何应用“英雄之旅”来创建数据视频。我们根据“英雄之旅”结构,从叙事阶段、声音设计和视觉设计方面对这48个数据视频进行了编码。基于我们的发现,我们提出了一个设计空间,通过数据视频创作,为“英雄之旅”的不同叙事部分(即出发、启蒙、回归)的叙事、视觉和声音定制设计提供实用指导。为了验证我们提出的设计空间,我们进行了一项用户研究,邀请20名参与者在有和没有我们设计空间指导的情况下设计数据视频,并由两位专家进行评估。结果表明,我们的设计空间为数据叙事者有效地创建具有“英雄之旅”的数据视频提供了有用且实用的指导。