Young Sonia N, Norris Elizabeth S, Shifflett Thomas B, Nisbet Daniel B, Saunders Brady E, Driver Caleb Z
Department of Physical Therapy, Western Kentucky University, Bowling Green, KY, USA.
Int J Exerc Sci. 2024 Aug 1;17(1):1183-1192. doi: 10.70252/AMXQ4966. eCollection 2024.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the test-retest reliability of the instrumented version of the modified Clinical Test of Sensory Interaction on Balance (i-mCTSIB) using the VirtuSense VirtuBalance System™ (VSTBalance), a virtual balance device, in healthy young adults. Fifty-four subjects aged 20-27 years (Mean age 23.07, SD ± 1.6), participated in the study. A one-group design was utilized. Three trials of the i-mCTSIB were performed on two separate days to measure the mean sway velocity of the trunk under four conditions. Within-day reliability of trials 1-3 was estimated with intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) and between-day reliability was estimated using the averages of trials 1-3 on day 1 and day 2 (ICC). Within-day reliability was moderate on day 1 (ICC = 0.511-0.672) and day 2 (ICC = 0.539 -0.677). Between-day reliability was moderate to good (ICC = 0.705-0.810). The lower bounds of the confidence intervals of within-day reliability estimates were 0.341-0.548, while the lower bounds of the confidence interval for the between-day reliability estimates were 0.390-0.671. Reliability of the VSTBalance for balance assessment using the i-mCTSIB test is moderate to good. Between-day reliability was higher than within-day reliability. When using the VSTBalance to assess balance with the i-mCTSIB, clinicians should provide practice of each condition contained in the test to improve reliability. The higher between-day reliability as compared to within-day reliability suggests that clinicians should use the averages of three trials when assessing balance performance change across time for each condition of the i-mCTSIB test when assessing balance using the VSTBalance.
本研究旨在使用虚拟平衡设备VirtuSense VirtuBalance System™(VSTBalance)评估改良版平衡感觉交互临床测试仪器版(i-mCTSIB)在健康年轻成年人中的重测信度。54名年龄在20至27岁之间(平均年龄23.07岁,标准差±1.6)的受试者参与了该研究。采用单组设计。在两个不同的日子里对i-mCTSIB进行了三次试验,以测量在四种条件下躯干的平均摆动速度。试验1至3的日内信度通过组内相关系数(ICC)进行估计,日间信度通过第1天和第2天试验1至3的平均值(ICC)进行估计。第1天(ICC = 0.511 - 0.672)和第2天(ICC = 0.539 - 0.677)的日内信度为中等。日间信度为中等至良好(ICC = 0.705 - 0.810)。日内信度估计的置信区间下限为0.341 - 0.548,而日间信度估计的置信区间下限为0.390 - 0.671。使用i-mCTSIB测试通过VSTBalance进行平衡评估的信度为中等至良好。日间信度高于日内信度。当使用VSTBalance通过i-mCTSIB评估平衡时,临床医生应提供测试中每种条件的练习以提高信度。与日内信度相比,较高的日间信度表明,当使用VSTBalance评估平衡时,临床医生在评估i-mCTSIB测试每种条件下随时间的平衡表现变化时应使用三次试验的平均值。