Meng Min, Hu Jiale, Lei Wenjuan, Tian Min, Liu Xiao, Lu Yali, Liu Enmei, Zhang Shu, Han Zhu, Li Qiu, Chen Yaolong
Chevidence Lab of Child & Adolescent Health, Children's Hospital of Chongqing Medical University, Chongqing, China.
National Clinical Research Center for Child Health and Disorders, Ministry of Education Key Laboratory of Child Development and Disorders, China International Science and Technology Cooperation Base of Child Development and Critical Disorders, Children's Hospital of Chongqing Medical University, Chongqing, China.
Transl Pediatr. 2024 Aug 31;13(8):1425-1438. doi: 10.21037/tp-24-198. Epub 2024 Aug 28.
Previously, we developed the Guidelines for the Management of Pediatric Off-Label Use of Drugs in China in addressing the need for standardization of pediatric off-label drug use. As the implementation of recommendations in Guidelines among healthcare professionals is weak, it is important to identify barriers to guideline implementation for developing appropriate strategies for specific settings and target groups. This study aimed to assess the difficulty and urgency in implementing the recommendations in the Guideline, identifying the factors affecting the implementation of these recommendations to realize the clinical translation of the Guideline.
A cross-sectional study was conducted from March 1 to June 17, 2022. Pediatricians, pharmacists, and health managers from all 31 mainland Chinese provinces were involved. The electronic questionnaires were distributed nationwide by The Clinical Pharmacology Group of the Pediatric Society of the Chinese Medical Association and the National Clinical Research Center for Child Health. Data analysis, including frequency, percentages, averages, and standard deviations was performed using Microsoft Excel 16.54. Chi-squared tests, multi-factor logistic regression, and linear regression were analyzed in SPSS 23.0. A Sankey diagram was constructed using R software.
A total of 869 valid questionnaires were collected from 491 participating organizations. More than half of the recommendations were implemented, and 12 recommendations were implemented more in tertiary hospitals than in secondary hospitals. The mean urgency scores of all 21 recommendations were over 5. The mean difficulty scores of all 21 recommendations were over 4. The percentage of the most urgent was 44.33%, and the least urgent was 1.45%. The most difficult portion was 12.03%, and the least difficult was 5.74%. Factors impacting the urgency and difficulty of guideline implementation were different, with common influences including the position, education level of clinicians and hospital level.
The recommendations in the Guideline for the Management of Pediatric Off-Label Use of Drugs are considered highly urgent for implementation in China. Nevertheless, the study revealed challenges in applying all 21 recommendations within clinical practice. The key factors affecting implementation include the position, education, experience, and hospital level of healthcare professionals. It is recommended to facilitate implementing the recommendations by sharing experience across various hospital levels, starting from high-level hospitals and extending to primary healthcare settings. Moreover, adjustments to the professional structure within hospitals are needed to enhance the management of off-label drug use in pediatric patients.
此前,我们制定了《中国儿童药物超说明书用药管理指南》,以满足儿童药物超说明书用药标准化的需求。由于医疗专业人员对《指南》中建议的执行力度较弱,识别指南实施的障碍对于为特定环境和目标群体制定适当策略很重要。本研究旨在评估实施《指南》中建议的难度和紧迫性,确定影响这些建议实施的因素,以实现《指南》的临床转化。
于2022年3月1日至6月17日进行了一项横断面研究。来自中国大陆31个省份的儿科医生、药剂师和卫生管理人员参与其中。电子问卷由中华医学会儿科学分会临床药理学组和国家儿童健康临床研究中心在全国范围内分发。使用Microsoft Excel 16.54进行数据分析,包括频率、百分比、平均值和标准差。在SPSS 23.0中进行卡方检验、多因素逻辑回归和线性回归分析。使用R软件构建桑基图。
共从491个参与机构收集到869份有效问卷。超过一半的建议得到了实施,12条建议在三级医院的实施情况比二级医院更好。所有21条建议的平均紧迫性得分均超过5分。所有21条建议的平均难度得分均超过4分。最紧急的建议占比为44.33%,最不紧急的为1.45%。最难的部分占比为12.03%,最不难的为5.74%。影响指南实施紧迫性和难度的因素不同,共同影响因素包括临床医生的职位、教育水平和医院级别。
《中国儿童药物超说明书用药管理指南》中的建议在中国被认为具有很高的实施紧迫性。然而,研究揭示了在临床实践中应用所有21条建议存在挑战。影响实施的关键因素包括医疗专业人员的职位、教育程度、经验和医院级别。建议通过在各级医院分享经验来促进建议的实施,从高级别医院开始并扩展到基层医疗环境。此外,需要调整医院内部的专业结构,以加强对儿科患者超说明书用药的管理。