Fiedler Julie M, Ayre Margaret L, Rosanowski Sarah, Slater Josh D
Melbourne Veterinary School, Faculty of Science, University of Melbourne, 250 Princes Highway, Werribee, Melbourne, VIC 3030, Australia.
School of Agriculture, Food and Ecosystem Sciences, University of Melbourne, Royal Parade, Parkville, Melbourne, VIC 3010, Australia.
Animals (Basel). 2024 Aug 26;14(17):2482. doi: 10.3390/ani14172482.
Anthropomorphizing can misinform the making of inferences about animal mental experiences. This is a consideration when implementing the Five Domains Model for animal welfare assessment. An online survey run in 2021 captured horse sector participants' perspectives about anthropomorphism and wellbeing in relation to horses. Most respondents, 82.9% ( = 431/520), believed that anthropomorphism could influence horse welfare and wellbeing. These respondents were then asked how, in their opinion, anthropomorphism might relate to horse welfare. A thematic analysis identified two themes: (1) 'Anthropomorphism can influence how people relate to horses' and (2) 'Anthropomorphism can have consequences for horse welfare and wellbeing'. The results suggested that experienced respondents were aware of the complexities surrounding anthropomorphic attitudes and that anthropomorphism can have beneficial and detrimental consequences on horse welfare and wellbeing. Benefits include a sense of relatedness to a horse, while detriments include the potential to misinterpret horse behaviors. The authors propose that anthropomorphism has a place in horse welfare and wellbeing when used critically and with caution. This study recommends that there is a need to actively manage anthropomorphism when organizations update policies and practices and implement the Five Domains Model. More research is required to understand the effects of anthropomorphism on horse-related practices.
拟人化可能会误导对动物心理体验的推断。这是在实施动物福利评估的五域模型时需要考虑的因素。2021年开展的一项在线调查收集了马匹行业参与者对与马相关的拟人化和福利状况的看法。大多数受访者,即82.9%(=431/520),认为拟人化会影响马的福利和健康状况。然后,这些受访者被问及在他们看来,拟人化可能如何与马的福利相关。主题分析确定了两个主题:(1)“拟人化会影响人们与马的相处方式”和(2)“拟人化会对马的福利和健康状况产生影响”。结果表明,有经验的受访者意识到围绕拟人化态度的复杂性,并且拟人化可能对马的福利和健康状况产生有益和有害的影响。好处包括与马有亲近感,而坏处包括可能误解马的行为。作者提出,当批判性且谨慎地使用拟人化时,它在马的福利和健康状况方面有一席之地。本研究建议,当组织更新政策和做法并实施五域模型时,有必要积极管理拟人化。需要更多研究来了解拟人化对与马相关的实践的影响。