Li Xuzhi, Huang Xinghua, Du Junyang, Zhang Ya, Lu Xiaosong, Jiang Jinlin, Wang Guoqing, Sun Li
State Environmental Protection Key Laboratory of Soil Environmental Management and Pollution Control, Nanjing Institute of Environmental Sciences, Ministry of Ecology and Environment, Nanjing 210042, China.
State Environmental Protection Key Laboratory of Soil Environmental Management and Pollution Control, Nanjing Institute of Environmental Sciences, Ministry of Ecology and Environment, Nanjing 210042, China; College of Environment Science and Engineering, Yangzhou University, Yangzhou 225127, China.
Sci Total Environ. 2024 Dec 1;954:176266. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2024.176266. Epub 2024 Sep 13.
Soil pollution caused by metal(loid)s is increasingly serious and poses unexpected risks to terrestrial organisms. Establishing soil quality standards is essential for assessing ecological risks of metal(loid)s and protecting soil ecosystems. However, the limited availability of metal(loid) ecotoxicological data has hampered the development of soil quality standards due to financial and practical constraints on toxicity testing. This study collected 77 normalization equations and 58 cross-species extrapolation equations to calculate the normalized EC (the added concentration causing a 10 % inhibition effect) of metal(loid)s under a representative scenario. A set of quantitative ion character-activity relationship (QICAR) models were then constructed using normalized EC and nine critical ionic characters (AR, AR/AW, BP, MP, Z/r, Z/r, X, σp, and |Log(K)|). Subsequently, these QICAR models were employed to predict ecotoxicological EC of 17 metal(loid)s to 12 soil species and coupled with species sensitivity distribution (SSD) to determine Predicted No Effect Concentration (PNEC). The results demonstrated the coupled QICAR-SSD model could effectively derive terrestrial PNEC for data-poor metal(loid)s, with errors between the predicted PNEC and reported soil standards (excluding soil background levels) from different countries mostly <0.3 orders of magnitude. Finally, soil ecological criteria (SEC) for 17 metal(loid)s were calculated using an added risk approach based on PNEC and national soil background concentration. Overall, the coupled model proposed here can provide a valuable supplement to the development of soil quality standards for numerous metal(loid)s in soil components.
由金属(类金属)造成的土壤污染日益严重,给陆地生物带来了意想不到的风险。制定土壤质量标准对于评估金属(类金属)的生态风险和保护土壤生态系统至关重要。然而,由于毒性测试存在资金和实际限制,金属(类金属)生态毒理学数据的有限可得性阻碍了土壤质量标准的制定。本研究收集了77个归一化方程和58个跨物种外推方程,以计算在代表性情景下金属(类金属)的归一化EC(导致10%抑制效应的添加浓度)。然后使用归一化EC和九个关键离子特征(AR、AR/AW、BP、MP、Z/r、Z/r、X、σp和|Log(K)|)构建了一组定量离子特征-活性关系(QICAR)模型。随后,这些QICAR模型被用于预测17种金属(类金属)对12种土壤物种的生态毒理学EC,并与物种敏感性分布(SSD)相结合以确定预测无效应浓度(PNEC)。结果表明,耦合的QICAR-SSD模型能够有效地推导数据匮乏的金属(类金属)的陆地PNEC,预测的PNEC与不同国家报告的土壤标准(不包括土壤背景水平)之间的误差大多<0.3个数量级。最后,基于PNEC和国家土壤背景浓度,采用额外风险方法计算了17种金属(类金属)的土壤生态标准(SEC)。总体而言,本文提出的耦合模型可为土壤成分中众多金属(类金属)的土壤质量标准制定提供有价值的补充。