Banaye Yazdipour Alireza, Ayyoubzadeh Seyed Mohammad, Nazary-Moghadam Salman, Arji Goli, Meigooni Fatemeh Sadat Mirmohammad, Kimiafar Khalil, Shahmoradi Leila
Department of Health Information Management and Medical Informatics, School of Allied Medical Sciences Tehran University of Medical Sciences Tehran Iran.
Students' Scientific Research Center (SSRC) Tehran University of Medical Sciences Tehran Iran.
Health Sci Rep. 2024 Sep 16;7(9):e2312. doi: 10.1002/hsr2.2312. eCollection 2024 Sep.
Nowadays, the demand for physical therapy services has grown significantly over the last few decades due to an aging population, a rise in chronic conditions, and increased awareness of the benefits of physical therapy for injury recovery and managing various health issues. Collecting and managing data from physical therapy services is highly significant and beneficial. One of the information management systems that facilitates data collection related to physical therapy services is a physical therapy registry. In this systematic review, we aimed to identify physical therapy registries worldwide and examine the characteristics and data elements of each registry.
PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and IEEE databases were searched from inception until March 19, 2023 by using keywords and Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) terms regarding "registries" and "physical therapy." The criteria for inclusion in the study were: (1) studies with the English language; (2) original studies, and online access to the physical therapy registry is available; (3) full-text available; (4) studies related to the aims of the study, and (5) studies that have sufficient available information regarding the minimum datasets and other characteristics physical therapy registry. The methodological quality of the included studies was independently assessed by two reviewers using the Effective Public Health Practice Project's (EPHPP) quality assessment tool.
Sixteen studies were eligible to be included. The findings of this review indicated that the oldest physical therapy registry was established in 1992, while the newest one was established in 2017. The USA has the highest number of physical therapy registries ( = 7). Ten registries were funded by the government, and the data source for most registries was collected in clinics ( = 11). The geographical coverage of 10 registries was national. All registries collected administrative data (such as sociodemographic data, healthcare provider's data, and others) and clinical data (such as diagnosis, type of physical therapy intervention, pain location, comorbidities, and others) through web-based systems. The data collection method in half of the registries was retrospective ( = 8 out of 16). According to the EPHPP quality assessment tool, 11 studies (73%) were rated as moderate, 3 (20%) as weak, and 1 (7%) as strong.
This systematic review found that most developed countries have implemented web-based physical therapy registries to collect administrative and clinical data at the national level. It is recommended that developing countries design and implement similar registries based on these characteristics and extracted data elements. Additionally, these registries should be designed to enable data sharing and interoperability with other international health information systems.
如今,在过去几十年里,由于人口老龄化、慢性病增多以及人们对物理治疗在损伤恢复和管理各种健康问题方面益处的认识提高,对物理治疗服务的需求显著增长。收集和管理物理治疗服务数据非常重要且有益。促进与物理治疗服务相关数据收集的信息管理系统之一是物理治疗登记处。在本系统评价中,我们旨在识别全球范围内的物理治疗登记处,并检查每个登记处的特征和数据元素。
从数据库创建至2023年3月19日,使用关于“登记处”和“物理治疗”的关键词及医学主题词(MeSH)检索PubMed、Scopus、Web of Science和IEEE数据库。纳入本研究的标准为:(1)英文研究;(2)原创研究,且可在线访问物理治疗登记处;(3)有全文;(4)与研究目的相关的研究;(5)关于最小数据集及物理治疗登记处其他特征有足够可用信息的研究。两名评审员使用有效公共卫生实践项目(EPHPP)质量评估工具独立评估纳入研究的方法学质量。
16项研究符合纳入标准。本评价结果表明,最早的物理治疗登记处成立于1992年,最新的成立于2017年。美国的物理治疗登记处数量最多(n = 7)。10个登记处由政府资助,大多数登记处的数据来源是在诊所收集的(n = 11)。10个登记处的地理覆盖范围是全国性的。所有登记处都通过基于网络的系统收集行政数据(如社会人口数据、医疗服务提供者数据等)和临床数据(如诊断、物理治疗干预类型、疼痛部位、合并症等)。一半登记处的数据收集方法是回顾性的(16个中有8个)。根据EPHPP质量评估工具,11项研究(73%)被评为中等,3项(20%)为薄弱,1项(7%)为有力。
本系统评价发现,大多数发达国家已实施基于网络的物理治疗登记处,以在国家层面收集行政和临床数据。建议发展中国家根据这些特征和提取的数据元素设计并实施类似的登记处。此外,这些登记处应设计为能够与其他国际卫生信息系统进行数据共享和互操作。