Pediatric Orthopaedic and Traumatology Unit, IRCCS Istituto Giannina Gaslini, Genova, Italy.
Vienna Bone and Growth Center, Währinger Gürtel 18-20, Vienna, Vienna, 1090, Austria.
Orphanet J Rare Dis. 2024 Sep 17;19(1):347. doi: 10.1186/s13023-024-03236-4.
Achondroplasia is the most common form of skeletal disorder with disproportionate short stature. Vosoritide is the first disease-specific, precision pharmacotherapy to increase growth velocity in children with achondroplasia. Limb surgery is a standard approach to increase height and arm span, improve proportionality and functionality, as well as correcting deformities. The aim of this study was to gain expert opinion on the combined use of vosoritide and limb surgery in children and adolescents with achondroplasia.
An international expert panel of 17 clinicians and orthopaedic surgeons was convened, and a modified Delphi process undertaken. The panel reviewed 120 statements for wording, removed any unnecessary statements, and added any that they felt were missing. There were 26 statements identified as facts that were not included in subsequent rounds of voting. A total of 97 statements were rated on a ten-point scale where 1 was 'Completely disagree' and 10 'Completely agree'. A score of ≥ 7 was identified as agreement, and ≤ 4 as disagreement. All experts who scored a statement ≤ 4 were invited to provide comments.
There was 100% agreement with several statements including, "Achieve a target height, arm span or upper limb length to improve daily activities" (mean level of agreement [LoA] 9.47, range 8-10), the "Involvement of a multidisciplinary team in a specialist centre to follow up the patient" (mean LoA 9.67, range 7-10), "Planning a treatment strategy based on age and pubertal stage" (mean LoA 9.60, range 8-10), and "Identification of short- and long-term goals, based on individualised treatment planning" (mean LoA 9.27, range 7-10), among others. The sequence of a combined approach and potential impact on the physes caused disagreement, largely due to a lack of available data.
It is clear from the range of responses that this modified Delphi process is only the beginning of new considerations, now that a medical therapy for achondroplasia is available. Until data on a combined treatment approach are available, sharing expert opinion is a vital way of providing support and guidance to the clinical community.
软骨发育不全是一种最常见的骨骼发育障碍,其特征为不成比例的身材矮小。Vosoritide 是首个针对疾病的精准治疗药物,可增加软骨发育不全患儿的生长速度。肢体手术是一种增加身高和臂展、改善比例和功能以及矫正畸形的标准方法。本研究旨在就软骨发育不全患儿和青少年中联合使用 vosoritide 和肢体手术获取专家意见。
召集了一个由 17 名临床医生和矫形外科医生组成的国际专家小组,并采用改良 Delphi 法进行研究。该小组对 120 条陈述进行了措辞审查,删除了任何不必要的陈述,并添加了他们认为缺失的陈述。有 26 条被确定为事实的陈述未包含在随后的投票环节中。共有 97 条陈述采用 10 分制进行评分,其中 1 分表示“完全不同意”,10 分表示“完全同意”。评分≥7 表示同意,评分≤4 表示不同意。所有评分≤4 的专家均受邀发表意见。
多项陈述获得了 100%的一致意见,包括“实现目标身高、臂展或上肢长度,以改善日常活动”(平均同意水平[LoA]为 9.47,范围为 8-10)、“在专科中心由多学科团队参与对患者进行随访”(平均 LoA 为 9.67,范围为 7-10)、“根据年龄和青春期阶段规划治疗策略”(平均 LoA 为 9.60,范围为 8-10)和“根据个体化治疗计划确定短期和长期目标”(平均 LoA 为 9.27,范围为 7-10)等。由于缺乏可用数据,联合治疗方案的先后顺序及其对骺板的潜在影响存在分歧。
从各种回复来看,这种改良 Delphi 法只是一个新的考虑起点,因为现在软骨发育不全已有了一种治疗药物。在联合治疗方法的数据可用之前,分享专家意见是为临床医生提供支持和指导的重要方式。