Alfried Krupp Hospital, Essen, Germany (M.B., S.P.-P., J.K.F., D.S., R.V., M.K.).
Florence Nightingale Hospital, Düsseldorf, Germany (M.B.).
Stroke. 2024 Nov;55(11):2661-2668. doi: 10.1161/STROKEAHA.124.046859. Epub 2024 Sep 18.
Moyamoya angiopathy (MMA) is an important cause of juvenile stroke but an overall rare disease among European populations compared with East Asian cohorts. Consecutively, hemorrhagic MMA is described well in East Asian cohorts, but knowledge in non-Asian patients is limited. Literature suggests that disease presentation may vary between those cohorts, also including hemorrhage frequencies. Hence, this article aims to analyze hemorrhagic MMA in European patients.
We screened for patients of European origin with MMA from a single-center consecutive database of a German hospital specialized on MMA. Those who had a record of intracranial hemorrhage were analyzed individually regarding the type of hemorrhage and use of antiplatelet therapy before and after bleeding onset. To identify associated factors of intracranial hemorrhage, an age- and sex-matched control group was identified from the pool of patients without a history of hemorrhage. Both groups had a comparable follow-up time and were compared in terms of disease presentation, therapeutic interventions, and imaging characteristics, using both univariate tests and multivariate logistic regression analysis.
From a pool of 332 patients with MMA we identified 288 of European ancestry. From those, 36 had a record of intracranial hemorrhage (12.5%). Thirty-three patients presenting with 37 events were included for further analysis and case-control-comparison. Most events were intracerebral hemorrhage (n=20; 54%) and subarachnoid hemorrhage (n=11; 30%). 78% developed hemorrhage although no antiplatelet therapy was in use (n=29). Seven patients developed intracranial hemorrhage ipsilateral to prior bypass surgery (21%), while 29 of the control patients had a bypass surgery (88%; =0.0001). There was no significant difference in terms of unilateral or bilateral disease type, history of hypertension, as well as imaging characteristics (high Suzuki stage and the presence of collateral pathways in conventional angiography, as well as ischemic defects and the presence of microbleeds on cerebral magnetic resonance imaging; >0.05 in multivariate analysis, respectively).
Bypass surgery was negatively associated with the development of intracranial hemorrhage in MMA in European patients. There was no difference in terms of a history of hypertension between groups, indicating that blood pressure is not the major contributor for rupture of fragile collateral vessels. The investigated imaging characteristics were not associated to hemorrhage onset and, therefore, are not suitable as a tool of screening for patients at risk.
烟雾病(Moyamoya angiopathy,MMA)是青少年中风的一个重要原因,但在欧洲人群中的总体发病率相对较低,与东亚队列相比更是如此。因此,在东亚队列中对出血性 MMA 有很好的描述,但在非亚洲患者中的知识有限。文献表明,疾病表现可能在这些队列之间有所不同,包括出血频率。因此,本文旨在分析欧洲患者的出血性 MMA。
我们从一家专门治疗 MMA 的德国医院的单中心连续数据库中筛选出来自欧洲血统的 MMA 患者。对那些有颅内出血记录的患者,根据出血类型和出血前及出血后的抗血小板治疗情况进行单独分析。为了确定颅内出血的相关因素,从无出血史的患者中确定了一个年龄和性别匹配的对照组。两组具有可比的随访时间,并通过单变量检验和多变量逻辑回归分析比较两组的疾病表现、治疗干预和影像学特征。
在 MMA 患者的 332 名患者中,我们发现有 288 名来自欧洲血统。其中,36 名患者有颅内出血记录(12.5%)。33 名患者出现 37 次事件,纳入进一步分析和病例对照比较。大多数事件为脑出血(n=20;54%)和蛛网膜下腔出血(n=11;30%)。尽管未使用抗血小板治疗,但仍有 78%的患者发生出血(n=29)。7 名患者在先前搭桥手术后同侧发生颅内出血(21%),而对照组 29 名患者进行了搭桥手术(88%;=0.0001)。在单侧或双侧疾病类型、高血压史以及影像学特征方面无显著差异(单侧或双侧病变、高血压史、常规血管造影中 Suzuki 分期高且侧支循环存在、脑磁共振成像上存在缺血性缺陷和微出血;多变量分析分别>0.05)。
在欧洲 MMA 患者中,搭桥手术与颅内出血的发生呈负相关。两组间高血压史无差异,表明血压不是脆弱侧支血管破裂的主要原因。所研究的影像学特征与出血发作无关,因此不适合作为筛查高危患者的工具。