Wallenhammar Ann-Charlotte, Vilvert Elisa, Bergqvist Sanna, Olson Åke, Berlin Anna
Rural Economy and Agricultural Society Konsult AB, Gamla vägen 5G, 702 27, Örebro, Sweden.
Department of Forest Mycology and Plant Pathology, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Box 7026, 750 07, Uppsala, Sweden.
Environ Evid. 2022 Jun 21;11(1):22. doi: 10.1186/s13750-022-00277-9.
BACKGROUND: Oilseed rape (OSR; Brassica napus L.) is a highly valued crop for food, feed and industrial use. It is primarily grown in temperate climates, and over recent decades, its area of production and profitability have increased. Concurrently, several diseases negatively impact OSR production. Diseases caused by soil-borne pathogens, pose a risk of substantial yield loss since crop rotation schemes have become narrow as the time lapse between OSR crops in a field has been shortened. The aims of this paper were to provide an overview of plant protection measures available for OSR production and to identify knowledge gaps and areas where more research is needed. METHODS: This systematic map builds on a previously published protocol and follows the ROSES reporting standard. The search strategy was developed in collaboration with stakeholders and designed to cover available scientific evidence for OSR disease management in climate zones relevant for Scandinavian crop production (Dfc, Dfb, Cfb and Cfa in the Köppen-Geiger climate classification). Five scientific databases were used to identify peer-reviewed literature, complemented by additional searches performed in grey literature. Articles were screened at three stages: the title, abstract and full text. The eligible publications included studies of OSR crops, and all measures to control crop disease in agricultural fields were considered eligible interventions. The comparator was intervention and no intervention, and the yield per unit area, disease suppression or an increase in crop quality were determined to be outcomes of interventions. A basic assessment of the experimental design of each study was performed to assess its eligibility. All articles were coded based on the following categories: the location and climate zone, disease, pathogen, intervention and management method, outcome and study design. Articles not reporting original data but judged to be relevant (i.e., review papers, books and notes of registration of cultivars) were saved in a separate category called "books, reviews and reports". REVIEW FINDINGS: A total of 4633 articles were collected through systematic searches. After duplicates were removed, 3513 articles were included in the screening process. After screening at the title and abstract levels, 897 articles were evaluated at the full text level, and 118 articles comprised the studies that met the eligibility criteria of the systematic map. The country (Canada) and region (Europe) with the largest OSR crop production areas also contributed the highest number of articles. In total, 17 different diseases were reported, with black leg (syn. Phoma stem canker) being the most studied disease. Nineteen different intervention methods or management types were examined. Cultivar resistance and pesticide application were the most studied control measures. CONCLUSION: We report scientific studies on plant disease protection measures for OSR based on field trials where the results are intended to be directly implemented in crop production management. The map clearly provides an overview of research progress throughout the time period chosen, and it identifies knowledge gaps regarding important diseases where only a few studies have been published, for example, diseases caused by viruses.
背景:油菜(OSR;甘蓝型油菜)是一种具有很高价值的作物,可用于食品、饲料和工业用途。它主要生长在温带气候地区,近几十年来,其种植面积和盈利能力都有所增加。与此同时,几种病害对油菜生产产生了负面影响。由土壤传播病原体引起的病害会造成大幅减产的风险,因为随着田间油菜作物种植间隔时间的缩短,作物轮作方案变得有限。本文的目的是概述油菜生产中可用的植物保护措施,并确定知识空白以及需要更多研究的领域。 方法:本系统综述基于先前发表的方案构建,并遵循ROSES报告标准。搜索策略是与利益相关者合作制定的,旨在涵盖与斯堪的纳维亚作物生产相关气候区(柯本-盖格气候分类中的Dfc、Dfb、Cfb和Cfa)油菜病害管理的现有科学证据。使用五个科学数据库来识别同行评审文献,并辅以在灰色文献中进行的额外搜索。文章分三个阶段进行筛选:标题、摘要和全文。符合条件的出版物包括油菜作物的研究,所有控制农田作物病害的措施都被视为符合条件的干预措施。对照是干预和不干预,单位面积产量、病害抑制或作物品质提高被确定为干预的结果。对每项研究的实验设计进行基本评估以评估其是否符合条件。所有文章根据以下类别进行编码:地点和气候区、病害、病原体、干预和管理方法、结果和研究设计。未报告原始数据但被判定为相关的文章(即综述论文、书籍和品种登记记录)保存在一个名为“书籍、综述和报告”的单独类别中。 综述结果:通过系统搜索共收集到4633篇文章。去除重复项后,3513篇文章进入筛选过程。在标题和摘要层面筛选后,897篇文章进入全文评估,118篇文章构成了符合系统综述资格标准的研究。油菜种植面积最大的国家(加拿大)和地区(欧洲)贡献的文章数量也最多。总共报告了17种不同的病害,其中黑胫病(同义词:茎点霉茎溃疡病)是研究最多的病害。研究了19种不同的干预方法或管理类型。品种抗性和农药施用是研究最多的控制措施。 结论:我们报告了基于田间试验的油菜植物病害保护措施的科学研究,其结果旨在直接应用于作物生产管理。该综述清楚地概述了所选时间段内的研究进展,并确定了关于重要病害的知识空白,例如由病毒引起的病害,针对这些病害只有少数研究发表。
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2022-2-1
Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2009-7-9
Early Hum Dev. 2020-11
Plant Dis. 2007-2
Fam Med. 2005-5