Mologni Fabio, Moffat Chandra E, Pither Jason
Department of Biology, and Institute for Biodiversity, Resilience, and Ecosystem Services, I.K. Barber Faculty of Science, University of British Columbia Okanagan, 1177 Research Road, Kelowna, BC, V1V 1V7, Canada.
Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, Summerland Research and Development Centre, 4200 Highway #97, Summerland, BC, V0H 1Z0, Canada.
Environ Evid. 2023 Dec 14;12(1):31. doi: 10.1186/s13750-023-00320-3.
Globally, the structure and functioning of foreshore and riparian ecosystems are being dramatically impacted by non-native invasive plant species. Invasive species can outcompete and replace native species, modify geochemical and hydraulic cycles, alter trophic processes, and change the composition and structure of communities above and below ground. However, these impacts are often investigated in isolation, even though one invasive species might increase or mitigate the impacts of others (i.e. cumulative impacts), potentially with cascading effects. Although cumulative impacts have long been studied within other environmental contexts, research on the cumulative impacts of invasive species is comparatively scarce. We aim to develop a protocol to systematically identify and collate evidence on the individual and cumulative impacts of a set of plant species invasive in foreshore and riparian ecosystems of British Columbia, Canada. Our primary question is: what evidence is available on the individual and cumulative impacts of invasive plants in the riparian and foreshore ecosystems of British Columbia, Canada? In addition, our systematic map will identify the strengths and gaps in knowledge pertaining to invasive plant species impacts in foreshore and riparian ecosystems, with the ultimate goal of facilitating the development of evidence-based management strategies.
We identified the research topic and the primary and secondary questions with the support of stakeholders. We then devised a flexible string that allows for searching target invasive species. Using this string, we searched the literature for pilot species that aided the iterative development of the protocol. Once all target species are identified, we will carry out a systematic literature search on their impacts. We will search Web of Science and the CABI compendium for invasive species. We will include studies if they (i) refer to the target invasive species, (ii) focus on its environmental impacts and (iii) investigate such impacts in riparian ecosystems (iv) within North America (i.e. Canada and U.S.A.). We will use a two-stage screening process: titles and abstracts first, then the full manuscript. From each source, we will extract impact description, ecosystem component impacted, and magnitude and directionality of impacts. We will include a publicly available database of studies, descriptive statistics, and a narrative summary within our synthesis outcomes.
在全球范围内,滨海和河岸生态系统的结构与功能正受到非本地入侵植物物种的巨大影响。入侵物种能够胜过并取代本地物种,改变地球化学和水文循环,改变营养过程,并改变地上和地下群落的组成与结构。然而,这些影响往往是孤立地进行研究,尽管一种入侵物种可能会增强或减轻其他物种的影响(即累积影响),并可能产生连锁效应。虽然长期以来在其他环境背景下一直在研究累积影响,但关于入侵物种累积影响的研究相对较少。我们旨在制定一个方案,以系统地识别和整理关于一组入侵加拿大不列颠哥伦比亚省滨海和河岸生态系统的植物物种的个体和累积影响的证据。我们的主要问题是:关于加拿大不列颠哥伦比亚省河岸和滨海生态系统中入侵植物的个体和累积影响,有哪些可用证据?此外,我们的系统图谱将确定与滨海和河岸生态系统中入侵植物物种影响相关的知识优势和差距,最终目标是促进基于证据的管理策略的制定。
我们在利益相关者的支持下确定了研究主题以及主要和次要问题。然后我们设计了一个灵活的检索式,用于搜索目标入侵物种。利用这个检索式,我们在文献中搜索有助于该方案迭代发展的试点物种。一旦确定了所有目标物种,我们将对它们的影响进行系统的文献检索。我们将在《科学引文索引》和CABI生物文摘中搜索入侵物种。如果研究(i)提及目标入侵物种,(ii)关注其环境影响,(iii)在北美(即加拿大和美国)的河岸生态系统中调查此类影响,我们将纳入这些研究。我们将使用两阶段筛选过程:首先是标题和摘要,然后是完整手稿。从每个来源中,我们将提取影响描述、受影响的生态系统组成部分以及影响的程度和方向性。我们将在综合结果中纳入一个公开可用的研究数据库、描述性统计数据和叙述性总结。