Hajian-Tilaki Adel, Kenari Reza Esmaeilzadeh, Farahmandfar Reza, Razavi Razie
Department of Food Science and Technology, Sari Agricultural Sciences & Natural Resources University (SANRU), Sari, 48181-68984, Iran.
Heliyon. 2024 Sep 6;10(17):e37550. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e37550. eCollection 2024 Sep 15.
Iran, a leading honey-producing country, faces challenges in honey exports. This study aimed to evaluate the melissopalynological and physicochemical characteristics of local honeys belonging to Iranian flora, and compare them with Iranian commercial honeys. For this purpose, seven local honey samples were collected from Iran's renowned floristic regions, alongside seven commercial multi-floral honeys from a supermarket. Moisture content (MC), total solids (TS), pH, free acidity (FA), ash, electrical conductivity (EC), sugar profile, hydroxymethyl furfural (HMF), diastase number (DN), and proline were assessed. The sugar profile was analyzed by high-performance liquid chromatography with a refractive index detector (HPLC-RID). Pollen analysis classified local honeys as multi-floral. The results revealed that MC, TS, pH, FA, ash, and EC values in both local and commercial samples conformed to approved standards (Codex Alimentarius and European Union). Two local and one commercial sample exclusively satisfied the sucrose standard level. Of the local honeys, two samples complied with HMF standard, while five fulfilled DN criterion, and four had proline values within acceptable ranges. Conversely, HMF (56.32-228.11 mg/kg), DN (3.13-7.22 Schade units/g), and proline (109.84-173.86 mg/kg) levels in all commercial samples failed to meet the standard. A significant correlation was found between ash and EC (r = 0.915, p < 0.01) in local honeys, whereas no strong correlation (r = 0.299) existed in commercial samples. Hierarchical cluster analysis confirmed that Iranian honeys lacked clustering by botanical origin, possibly due to extensive sugar adulteration or thermal treatment. Overall, study findings confirmed the significantly inferior quality of Iranian commercial honeys compared to local varieties, albeit some local samples also exhibited quality concerns. Accordingly, it is recommended that regulatory bodies provide periodic training for beekeepers and establish monitoring programs to enhance honey quality, thereby boosting Iran's share in the global honey export market.
伊朗作为主要的蜂蜜生产国,在蜂蜜出口方面面临挑战。本研究旨在评估属于伊朗植物区系的本地蜂蜜的蜂蜜花粉学和物理化学特性,并将其与伊朗商业蜂蜜进行比较。为此,从伊朗著名的植物区系地区采集了七个本地蜂蜜样本,同时从一家超市采集了七种商业多花蜂蜜。评估了水分含量(MC)、总固体(TS)、pH值、游离酸度(FA)、灰分、电导率(EC)、糖谱、羟甲基糠醛(HMF)、淀粉酶值(DN)和脯氨酸。通过配备示差折光检测器的高效液相色谱法(HPLC-RID)分析糖谱。花粉分析将本地蜂蜜归类为多花蜂蜜。结果显示,本地和商业样本中的MC、TS、pH值、FA、灰分和EC值均符合认可标准(食品法典委员会和欧盟)。两个本地样本和一个商业样本完全符合蔗糖标准水平。在本地蜂蜜中,有两个样本符合HMF标准,五个样本满足DN标准,四个样本的脯氨酸值在可接受范围内。相反,所有商业样本中的HMF(56.32 - 228.11毫克/千克)、DN(3.13 - 7.22沙德单位/克)和脯氨酸(109.84 - 173.86毫克/千克)水平均未达到标准。本地蜂蜜中灰分与EC之间存在显著相关性(r = 0.915,p < 0.01),而商业样本中不存在强相关性(r = 0.299)。层次聚类分析证实,伊朗蜂蜜缺乏按植物来源的聚类,这可能是由于大量的糖掺假或热处理。总体而言,研究结果证实,与本地品种相比,伊朗商业蜂蜜的质量明显较差,尽管一些本地样本也存在质量问题。因此,建议监管机构为养蜂人提供定期培训,并建立监测计划以提高蜂蜜质量,从而增加伊朗在全球蜂蜜出口市场中的份额。