Division of Basic Medical Sciences, Department of Medical Education, Kocaeli University Faculty of Medicine, Kocaeli, Turkey.
Division of Internal Medical Sciences, Department of Family Medicine, Kocaeli University Faculty of Medicine, Kocaeli, Turkey.
BMC Med Educ. 2024 Sep 19;24(1):1026. doi: 10.1186/s12909-024-05996-w.
High-fidelity simulations play a crucial role in preparing for high-mortality events like cardiopulmonary arrest, emphasizing the need for rapid and accurate intervention. Proficiency in cardiopulmonary resuscitation(CPR) requires a strong self-efficacy(SE); training for both is crucial. This study assesses the impact of Advanced Life Support(ALS) simulation on SE changes in final-year medical students.
This mixed-methods prospective simulation study involved medical students in emergency medicine internships, examining self-efficacy perceptions regarding ALS technical skills(ALS-SEP). A comparison was made between students who underwent scenario-based ALS simulation training and those who did not. Competencies in chest compression skills were assessed, and the concordance between ALS-SEP scores and observed CPR performances were evaluated. Focus group interviews were conducted and analyzed using content analysis techniques.
The study involved 80 students, with 53 in the experimental group(EG) and 27 in the control group(CG). The EG, underwent simulation training, showed a significantly higher ALS-SEP change than the CG(p < 0.05). However, there was low concordance between pre-simulation SEP and actual performance. Compression skills success rates were inadequate. Qualitative analysis revealed main themes as"learning"(32.6%), "self-efficacy"(29%), "simulation method"(21.3%), and "development"(16.5%).
Post-simulation, students reported improved SEP and increased readiness for future interventions. The findings and qualitative statements support the effectiveness of simulation practices in bridging the gap between SEP and performance. Utilizing simulation-based ALS training enhances learners' belief in their capabilities, raises awareness of their competencies, and encourages reflective thinking. Given the importance of high SEP for ALS, simulation trainings correlating self-efficacy perception and performance may significantly reduce potential medical errors stemming from a disparity between perceived capability and actual performance.
高保真模拟在心肺骤停等高死亡率事件的准备中起着至关重要的作用,强调需要快速、准确的干预。心肺复苏(CPR)的熟练程度需要很强的自我效能感(SE);培训是至关重要的。本研究评估高级生命支持(ALS)模拟对医学实习生自我效能感变化的影响。
这是一项混合方法前瞻性模拟研究,涉及急诊医学实习的医学生,考察了他们对 ALS 技术技能(ALS-SEP)的自我效能感感知。比较了接受基于情景的 ALS 模拟培训的学生和未接受培训的学生。评估了学生的胸外按压技能,评估了 ALS-SEP 评分与观察到的 CPR 表现之间的一致性。进行了焦点小组访谈,并使用内容分析技术进行了分析。
该研究共涉及 80 名学生,实验组(EG)有 53 名,对照组(CG)有 27 名。EG 组接受了模拟培训,其 ALS-SEP 变化明显高于 CG 组(p<0.05)。然而,预模拟 SEP 与实际表现之间的一致性较低。按压技能成功率不足。定性分析揭示了三个主要主题:“学习”(32.6%)、“自我效能”(29%)、“模拟方法”(21.3%)和“发展”(16.5%)。
模拟后,学生报告 SEP 提高,对未来干预的准备更加充分。研究结果和定性陈述支持模拟实践在弥合 SEP 和表现之间差距的有效性。利用基于模拟的 ALS 培训增强了学习者对自己能力的信心,提高了对自己能力的认识,并鼓励了反思性思维。鉴于 ALS 高 SEP 的重要性,将自我效能感感知与表现相关联的模拟培训可能会显著减少因感知能力和实际表现之间的差距而导致的潜在医疗错误。