Bailey Annette, Bailey Renee, Newman Gary, Barrett Andrew, Nguyen Megan, Lindsay Jabari
Toronto Metropolitan University (Formerly Ryerson University), Toronto, Canada.
University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
J Child Adolesc Trauma. 2023 Mar 9;17(3):999-1012. doi: 10.1007/s40653-023-00526-0. eCollection 2024 Sep.
Multiple and continuous traumatic events experienced by Black men impose altering effects on their identities, and their mentalization and presentation of themselves in society. However, the unique dynamics of the impact of trauma in shaping Black men's identities are not well understood, because their experiences with trauma are not well documented. This paper is a secondary analysis of the qualitative component of a mixed method study that explored trauma, social support, and resilience among 103 racialized youth survivors of gun violence in Toronto, Canada. The analysis for this paper specifically focused on young Black male participants in the study to understand their disproportional experiences with gun violent trauma. Thematic analysis of their narrative demonstrated three themes: 1) trapped by the trauma of systemic oppression; 2) identity marred by the trauma of systemic oppression; and 3) masculinity shifted by the trauma of systemic oppression. The thematic mapping of themes and subthemes yielded the trauma-altered identity (TAI), a concept coined to represent the intersections of trauma, systemic oppression, masculinity, and the identity of Black male survivors. Using a metaphoric artwork to conceptualise the TAI, we explore its psychosocial impacts and set strategies for deconstructing its influence on Black men. While we acknowledge that trauma experiences may vary among Black males, we recognise that understanding intersections of risks associated with trauma among young Black males presents opportunities for policy discussions, advocacy, and social justice reforms.
黑人男性所经历的多重且持续的创伤性事件对他们的身份认同、心理化过程以及他们在社会中的自我呈现产生了改变性的影响。然而,创伤在塑造黑人男性身份认同方面的独特动态尚未得到充分理解,因为他们的创伤经历没有得到很好的记录。本文是对一项混合方法研究的定性部分的二次分析,该研究探讨了加拿大多伦多103名经历过枪支暴力的种族化青年幸存者的创伤、社会支持和复原力。本文的分析特别关注了该研究中的年轻黑人男性参与者,以了解他们在枪支暴力创伤方面不成比例的经历。对他们叙述的主题分析揭示了三个主题:1)被系统性压迫的创伤所困;2)身份认同因系统性压迫的创伤而受损;3)男子气概因系统性压迫的创伤而转变。主题和子主题的主题映射产生了创伤改变身份(TAI)这一概念,该概念旨在代表创伤、系统性压迫、男子气概以及黑人男性幸存者身份的交叉点。通过一幅隐喻性的艺术作品来概念化TAI,我们探讨了它的心理社会影响,并制定了解构其对黑人男性影响的策略。虽然我们承认黑人男性的创伤经历可能各不相同,但我们认识到,了解年轻黑人男性中与创伤相关的风险交叉点为政策讨论、宣传和社会正义改革提供了机会。