This work aims to serve as a comprehensive guide to properly characterize solid-contact ion-selective electrodes (SC-ISEs) for long-term use as they advance toward calibration-free sensors. The lack of well-defined SC-ISE performance criteria limits the ability to compare results and track progress in the field. Laser-induced graphene (LIG) is a rapid and scalable method that, by adjusting the CO laser parameters, can create LIG substrates with tunable surface properties, including wettability, surface chemistry, and morphology. Herein, we fabricate laser-induced graphene (LIG) solid-contact electrodes using different laser settings and subsequently convert them into ion-selective sensors using a potassium-selective membrane. We measure the aforementioned tunable surface properties and correlate them with resultant low-frequency capacitance and water layer formation in an effort to pinpoint their effects on the sensitivity (Nernstian response), reproducibility (E°' variation), and potential stability of the LIG-based SC-ISEs. More specifically, we demonstrate that the surface wettability of the LIG substrate, which can be tuned by controlling the lasing parameters, can be modified to exhibit hydrophobic (contact angle > 90°) and even highly hydrophobic surfaces (contact angle ≈ 130°) to help reduce sensor drift. Recommendations are also provided to ensure proper and robust characterization of SC-ISEs for long-term and continuous measurements. Ultimately, we believe that a comprehensive understanding of the correlation between LIG tunable surface properties and SC-ISE performance can be used to improve the electrochemical behavior and stability of SC-ISEs designed with a wide range of materials beyond LIG.