Calvey H, Davis M, Williams R
J Hepatol. 1985;1(2):141-51. doi: 10.1016/s0168-8278(85)80762-5.
Sixty-four patients admitted with acute alcoholic hepatitis, with or without underlying cirrhosis, were randomized regardless of encephalopathy to receive a controlled diet either alone, or supplemented orally, nasogastrically, or intravenously as necessary, with 2000 kCal and 10 g nitrogen daily. Whether this came from a conventional protein source or a branched chain amino acid enriched formulation was also randomly determined. In the absence of renal failure, nitrogen intakes of 10 g or more daily were invariably associated with positive nitrogen balance, but complications of liver dysfunction prevented the attainment of significantly more positive balance in the supplemented groups than in controls. Neither in the series as a whole, nor in any identifiable subgroup of patients, was mortality affected by treatment. Changes in prothrombin time and in measured nutritional parameters during the study did not differ between supplemented and control groups, and the observed changes in midarm muscle circumference appeared to reflect changes in degree of fluid retention. Neither enteral nor parenteral branched chain amino acids showed any consistent effect upon encephalopathy.
64例因急性酒精性肝炎入院的患者,无论有无潜在肝硬化,均不考虑是否存在肝性脑病,随机分为两组,一组仅接受控制饮食,另一组根据需要经口服、鼻饲或静脉补充每日2000千卡热量和10克氮。这些热量和氮是来源于传统蛋白质来源还是富含支链氨基酸的配方也随机确定。在没有肾衰竭的情况下,每日摄入10克或更多的氮总是与氮平衡为正相关,但肝功能障碍的并发症使得补充组的氮平衡比对照组显著更正向的情况无法实现。无论是在整个系列中,还是在任何可识别的患者亚组中,治疗均未影响死亡率。在研究期间,补充组和对照组之间凝血酶原时间和所测量的营养参数的变化并无差异,并且观察到的上臂中部肌肉周长的变化似乎反映了液体潴留程度的变化。肠内或肠外补充支链氨基酸对肝性脑病均未显示出任何一致的效果。