Scuola Normale Superiore, Pisa, Italy.
Médecins Sans Frontières, Operational Centre Brussels (MSF OCB), Karachi, Pakistan.
BMC Infect Dis. 2024 Sep 27;24(1):1054. doi: 10.1186/s12879-024-09925-6.
BACKGROUND: Hepatitis C virus (HCV) antibody self-testing (HCVST) may help expand screening access and support HCV elimination efforts. Despite potential benefits, HCVST is not currently implemented in Pakistan. This study aimed to assess the usability and acceptability of HCVST in a high HCV prevalence informal settlement in Karachi, Pakistan. METHODS: We performed a cross-sectional study in a hepatitis C clinic from April through June 2023. Participants were invited to perform a saliva-based HCVST (OraSure Technologies, USA) while following pictorial instructions. A study member evaluated test performance using a standardized checklist and provided verbal support if a step could not be completed. Perceived usability and acceptability were assessed using a semi-structured questionnaire. The HCVST was considered successful if the participant was able to complete all steps and correctly interpret test results. Overall concordance and positive and negative agreement were estimated in comparison with the HCVST result read by the study member (inter-reader concordance and agreement) and result of a second rapid HCV test (Abbott Diagnostics Korea Inc, South Korea) performed by a trained user (inter-operator concordance and agreement). RESULTS: The study included 295 participants of which 97 (32%) were illiterate. In total, 280 (95%, 95% CI 92-97%) HCVSTs were successful. Overall, 38 (13%) people performed the HCVST without verbal assistance, 67 (23%) needed verbal assistance in one step, 190 (64%) in two or more. Assistance was most often needed in managing the test buffer and test reading times. The inter-reader concordance was 96% and inter-operator concordance 93%. Inter-reader and inter-operator positive percent agreement were 84 and 70%, respectively. All participants reported they would use HCVST again and would recommend it to friends and family. CONCLUSION: Saliva-based HCVST was very well accepted in this clinic-based setting. However, many people requested verbal support in several steps, highlighting the need for clear instructions for use and test devices that are simple to use, particularly in low literacy settings. Moderately low positive percent agreement with the results of a rapid test performed by a trained user highlights potential uncertainty in the accuracy of HCVST in the hands of lay users.
背景:丙型肝炎病毒(HCV)抗体自我检测(HCVST)可能有助于扩大筛查范围,并支持消除 HCV 的努力。尽管有潜在的益处,但 HCVST 目前在巴基斯坦尚未实施。本研究旨在评估 HCVST 在巴基斯坦卡拉奇一个 HCV 高流行率的非正规住区的可用性和可接受性。
方法:我们在 2023 年 4 月至 6 月期间在一家丙型肝炎诊所进行了一项横断面研究。邀请参与者使用基于唾液的 HCVST(美国 OraSure 技术公司),同时遵循图片说明。一名研究成员使用标准化检查表评估测试性能,如果无法完成某一步骤,将提供口头支持。使用半结构化问卷评估感知的可用性和可接受性。如果参与者能够完成所有步骤并正确解释测试结果,则 HCVST 被认为是成功的。与研究成员读取的 HCVST 结果(读者间一致性和一致性)和由经过培训的用户(操作员间一致性和一致性)进行的第二次快速 HCV 测试(韩国 Abbott Diagnostics Korea Inc)进行比较,估计总体一致性和阳性及阴性一致性。
结果:该研究共纳入 295 名参与者,其中 97 名(32%)为文盲。共有 280 名(95%,95%CI 92-97%)HCVST 成功。总体而言,有 38 人(13%)无需口头帮助即可进行 HCVST,67 人(23%)在一步中需要口头帮助,190 人(64%)在两步或更多步中需要口头帮助。在管理测试缓冲液和测试读取时间方面,最需要口头帮助。读者间一致性为 96%,操作员间一致性为 93%。读者间和操作员间阳性百分一致率分别为 84%和 70%。所有参与者均表示他们将再次使用 HCVST,并将向朋友和家人推荐它。
结论:基于唾液的 HCVST 在该基于诊所的环境中非常受欢迎。然而,许多人在几个步骤中请求口头支持,这突出表明需要针对使用说明和测试设备进行清晰说明,特别是在低识字率的环境中。与由经过培训的用户进行的快速测试结果相比,阳性百分一致率较低,突出了 HCVST 在非专业用户手中的准确性存在潜在的不确定性。
Front Public Health. 2022
Diagnostics (Basel). 2021-2-23
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2023-9-20
Front Public Health. 2022
BMC Infect Dis. 2021-6-26