Dehghani-Arani Fateme, Kazemi Reza, Hallajian Amir-Homayun, Sima Sepehr, Boutimaz Samaneh, Hedayati Sepideh, Koushamoghadam Saba, Safarifard Razieh, Salehinejad Mohammad Ali
Faculty of Psychology and Educational Sciences, University of Tehran, Tehran 1417935840, Iran.
Faculty of Entrepreneurship, University of Tehran, Tehran 1738953355, Iran.
J Clin Med. 2024 Sep 10;13(18):5358. doi: 10.3390/jcm13185358.
: Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) has recently demonstrated significant potential in treating obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). However, its effectiveness depends on various parameters, including stimulation parameters, OCD subtypes and electrical fields (EFs) induced by rTMS in targeted brain regions that are less studied. : Using the PRISMA approach, we examined 27 randomized control trials (RCTs) conducted from 1985 to 2024 using rTMS for the treatment of OCD and conducted several meta-analyses to investigate the role of rTMS parameters, including the EFs induced by each rTMS protocol, and OCD subtypes on treatment efficacy. : A significant, medium effect size was found, favoring active rTMS (g = 0.59, < 0.0001), which was larger for the obsession subscale. Both supplementary motor area (SMA) rTMS (g = 0.82, = 0.048) and bilateral dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) rTMS (gPPC = 1.14, = 0.04) demonstrated large effect sizes, while the right DLPFC showed a significant moderate effect size for reducing OCD severity (g = 0.63, = 0.012). These protocols induced the largest EFs in dorsal cognitive, ventral cognitive and sensorimotor circuits. rTMS protocols targeting DLPFC produced the strongest electrical fields in cognitive circuits, while pre-supplementary motor area (pre-SMA) and orbitofrontal cortex (OFC) rTMS protocols induced larger fields in regions linked to emotional and affective processing in addition to cognitive circuits. The pre-SMA rTMS modulated more circuits involved in OCD pathophysiology-sensorimotor, cognitive, affective, and frontolimbic-with larger electrical fields than the other protocols. : While rTMS shows moderate overall clinical efficacy, protocols targeting ventral and dorsal cognitive and sensorimotor circuits demonstrate the highest potential. The pre-SMA rTMS appears to induce electrical fields in more circuits relevant to OCD pathophysiology.
重复经颅磁刺激(rTMS)最近在治疗强迫症(OCD)方面显示出巨大潜力。然而,其有效性取决于各种参数,包括刺激参数、OCD亚型以及rTMS在目标脑区诱导的电场(EFs),而对这些方面的研究较少。
我们采用PRISMA方法,审查了1985年至2024年期间使用rTMS治疗OCD的27项随机对照试验(RCT),并进行了多项荟萃分析,以研究rTMS参数的作用,包括每种rTMS方案诱导的电场以及OCD亚型对治疗效果的影响。
发现了显著的中等效应大小,支持主动rTMS(g = 0.59,P < 0.0001),在强迫观念子量表上效应更大。辅助运动区(SMA)rTMS(g = 0.82,P = 0.048)和双侧背外侧前额叶皮质(DLPFC)rTMS(gPPC = 1.14,P = 0.04)均显示出大的效应大小,而右侧DLPFC在降低OCD严重程度方面显示出显著的中等效应大小(g = 0.63,P = 0.012)。这些方案在背侧认知、腹侧认知和感觉运动回路中诱导出最大的电场。针对DLPFC的rTMS方案在认知回路中产生最强的电场,而预辅助运动区(pre - SMA)和眶额皮质(OFC)rTMS方案除了在认知回路外,还在与情绪和情感处理相关的区域诱导出更大的电场。与其他方案相比,pre - SMA rTMS通过更大的电场调节更多参与OCD病理生理的回路——感觉运动、认知、情感和额边缘回路。
虽然rTMS显示出中等的总体临床疗效,但针对腹侧和背侧认知及感觉运动回路的方案显示出最高潜力。pre - SMA rTMS似乎在更多与OCD病理生理相关的回路中诱导电场。