Kidneys donated after circulatory death (DCD) perform similarly to kidneys donated after brain death (DBD). However, the respective incidences of delayed graft function (DGF) differ. This questions the donor type-specific impact of early graft function on long-term outcomes. Using competing risk and Cox-regression analysis, we compared death-censored graft loss between types of early graft function: DGF (temporary dialysis dependency started within 7 days after transplantation), slow graft function (3-day plasma creatinine decline less than 10% per day), and immediate graft function. In 1061 DBD and 1605 DCD graft recipients (January 2014 until January 2023), graft survival was similar. DGF was associated with death-censored graft loss in DBD and DCD (adjusted hazard ratios: DGF in DBD: 1.79 [1.04-2.91], P = .027, DGF in DCD: 1.84 [1.18-2.87], P = .008; Reference: no DGF). Slow graft function was associated with death-censored graft loss in DBD, but not significantly in DCD (adjusted hazard ratios DBD: 2.82 (1.34-5.93), P = .007, and DCD: 1.54 (0.72-3.35), P = .262; Reference: immediate graft function). Early graft dysfunction has a differential impact on graft outcome in DBD and DCD. The differences between DBD and DCD should be accounted for in research and the clinic.