Gupta Aditya K, Taylor Daniel, Polla Ravi Shruthi, Wang Tong, Talukder Mesbah
Mediprobe Research Inc., London, ON, Canada.
Division of Dermatology, Department of Medicine, Temerty Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Skin Appendage Disord. 2024 Oct;10(5):383-390. doi: 10.1159/000539822. Epub 2024 Jul 20.
Oral antifungals were the earliest treatments to receive approval for the management of onychomycosis and have a long-standing record to support their efficacy. Topical antifungals and device-based treatments have been explored and some implemented in more recent years as alternatives to traditional oral antifungals. The present bibliometric analysis summarizes trends in publication frequency for onychomycosis treatment modalities over time and characterizes their body of literature in terms of types of studies available and relative level of evidence.
A comprehensive literature search was performed using Web of Science and SCOPUS databases.
Covering all publications from 1970 to present day, our search identified oral therapeutics = 295 articles ( = 63 randomized control trials [RCTs]), topical therapeutics = 358 articles ( = 72 RCTs), and device-based treatments = 158 articles ( = 37 RCTs). Spikes in research activity surround FDA approval of therapeutics for each treatment modality. Research activity within the last decade has focused on topical and device-based treatments. Evidence for efficacy of device-based treatments is lacking from relatively few high-quality RCTs.
With growing concern for non-dermatophyte mold onychomycosis and terbinafine resistance, researchers should validate the efficacy and safety of device-based treatments with high-quality studies.
口服抗真菌药物是最早获批用于治疗甲癣的药物,并且有长期记录证明其疗效。近年来,人们对局部抗真菌药物和基于器械的治疗方法进行了探索,其中一些已作为传统口服抗真菌药物的替代方法得以应用。本文献计量分析总结了随着时间推移甲癣治疗方式的发表频率趋势,并根据现有研究类型和相对证据水平对其文献进行了特征描述。
使用科学网和Scopus数据库进行了全面的文献检索。
涵盖1970年至今的所有出版物,我们的检索发现口服治疗方法有295篇文章(其中63篇为随机对照试验[RCT]),局部治疗方法有358篇文章(其中72篇为RCT),基于器械的治疗方法有158篇文章(其中37篇为RCT)。每种治疗方式的研究活动高峰都围绕着FDA对治疗药物的批准。过去十年的研究活动集中在局部和基于器械的治疗方法上。相对较少的高质量RCT缺乏基于器械的治疗方法疗效的证据。
随着对非皮肤癣菌性霉菌甲癣和特比萘芬耐药性的日益关注,研究人员应通过高质量研究验证基于器械的治疗方法的疗效和安全性。