Institute of Biogeochemistry and Pollutant Dynamics, ETH Zürich, 8092 Zürich, Switzerland.
Institute for Energy Efficient Buildings and Indoor Climate, E.ON ERC, RWTH Aachen, 52074 Aachen, Germany.
Environ Sci Process Impacts. 2024 Nov 13;26(11):1955-1974. doi: 10.1039/d4em00444b.
Hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) and so-called hydrofluoroolefins (HFOs) are used as refrigerants in air conditioning, refrigeration, chillers, heat pumps and devices for dehumidification and drying. However, many HFCs, including R-134a and R-125, have a high global warming potential and some of the HFCs and HFOs degrade atmospherically and form trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) as a persistent degradation product. Rising levels of TFA around the globe reveal an urgent need to replace fluorinated refrigerants with non-fluorinated working fluids to avoid direct emissions due to leakage, incorrect loading or removal. It is important, however, also to select refrigerants with high efficiencies to avoid increasing indirect CO emissions due to higher energy consumption during the use phase. The present study investigates the available non-fluorinated alternatives to fluorinated refrigerants and shows that a transition to non-fluorinated refrigerants, in general, is possible and has happened in many sectors already. Technically, there are only slight barriers to overcome in order to replace fluorinated refrigerants in almost all newly developed systems conforming to existing standards. Additionally, we show that alternatives are available even for some use cases for which derogations have been proposed in the EU PFAS restriction proposal and suggest making these derogations more specific to support a speedy transition to non-fluorinated refrigerants in all sectors.
氢氟碳化物 (HFCs) 和所谓的氢氟烯烃 (HFOs) 被用作空调、制冷、冷水机、热泵和除湿干燥设备中的制冷剂。然而,许多 HFCs,包括 R-134a 和 R-125,具有很高的全球变暖潜能值,并且一些 HFCs 和 HFOs 在大气中降解,并形成三氟乙酸 (TFA) 作为持久性降解产物。全球范围内 TFA 水平的上升表明,迫切需要用非氟化工作流体替代氟化制冷剂,以避免因泄漏、不正确的装载或去除而导致的直接排放。然而,选择具有高效率的制冷剂也很重要,以避免因使用阶段的更高能源消耗而导致间接 CO 排放量增加。本研究调查了氟化制冷剂的可用非氟化替代品,并表明向非氟化制冷剂的过渡一般是可能的,并且已经在许多部门发生。从技术上讲,为了在几乎所有符合现有标准的新开发系统中替代氟化制冷剂,只需克服一些细微的障碍。此外,我们还表明,即使对于欧盟 PFAS 限制提案中提出豁免的某些用例,也有替代品可用,并建议使这些豁免更加具体,以支持所有部门向非氟化制冷剂的快速过渡。