Chaigneau Megan, Grabell Julie, Wijnker Emil, Bowman Mackenzie, James Paula
Department of Medicine, Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario, Canada.
Canadian Hemophilia Society, Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario, Canada.
Haemophilia. 2024 Nov;30(6):1393-1399. doi: 10.1111/hae.15107. Epub 2024 Oct 5.
It is widely acknowledged that haemophilia affects women and girls, yet current testing recommendations for factor level and genetic testing vary and do not universally incorporate updated research. Canadian parents have expressed frustration at inconsistent recommendations and reported instances where delayed testing led to missed diagnosis and preventable bleeding.
Study aim was to explore and describe the practice of haemophilia-related testing of young girls in Canada.
A mixed methods study was carried out with two populations: (1) Nurses working in haemophilia care completed a survey regarding the current testing recommendations of their Haemophilia Treatment Centre (HTC), (2) Parents of obligate or potential haemophilia carriers completed a structured interview with questions about their family experience of haemophilia and testing decisions for daughters.
Twenty-six survey responses were received and showed wide variation in the usual recommendations of Canadian HTCs. Different factor level testing recommendations may be given to obligate and potential carriers despite no difference in bleeding risk. Only a minority of HTCs currently recommend an early baseline factor level (< 10 years) to obligate carriers (27%) or potential carriers (15%). For genetic testing of potential carriers, 70% of HTC would approve a family request for genetic testing of a minor with specific conditions. The majority of parents interviewed felt dissatisfied with their testing experience (58%) and highlighted many issues related to delayed testing recommendations.
Updated, nationally affirmed testing recommendations are needed that align with research on bleeding in women and girls affected by haemophilia.
人们普遍认识到血友病会影响女性和女孩,但目前关于因子水平检测和基因检测的建议各不相同,且并未普遍纳入最新研究成果。加拿大的家长们对不一致的建议表示不满,并报告了一些因检测延迟导致漏诊和可预防出血的案例。
本研究旨在探索和描述加拿大年轻女孩血友病相关检测的实践情况。
采用混合方法对两个人群进行研究:(1)从事血友病护理工作的护士完成了一项关于其血友病治疗中心(HTC)当前检测建议的调查;(2)血友病携带者或潜在携带者的父母完成了一次结构化访谈,问题涉及他们家庭的血友病经历以及女儿的检测决策。
共收到26份调查问卷回复,结果显示加拿大各HTC的常规建议存在很大差异。尽管出血风险没有差异,但对于血友病携带者和潜在携带者可能会给出不同的因子水平检测建议。目前只有少数HTC建议对血友病携带者(27%)或潜在携带者(15%)在早期(<10岁)进行基线因子水平检测。对于潜在携带者的基因检测,70%的HTC会批准在特定条件下家庭对未成年人进行基因检测的请求。大多数接受访谈的家长对检测经历不满意(58%),并强调了许多与检测建议延迟相关的问题。
需要更新并得到全国认可的检测建议,使其与受血友病影响的女性和女孩出血情况的研究结果相一致。