Suppr超能文献

作为诙谐能动者的世界——唐娜·哈拉维论知识的客体

The world as witty agent-Donna Haraway on the object of knowledge.

作者信息

Trächtler Jasmin

机构信息

Department of Humanities and Theology, Institute for Political Science and Philosophy, Technical University Dortmund, Dortmund, Germany.

出版信息

Front Psychol. 2024 Sep 20;15:1389575. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1389575. eCollection 2024.

Abstract

In her essay "Situated Knowledges," the biologist and philosopher of science Donna Haraway tackles the question of scientific objectivity from a feminist perspective and opts for a 're-vision' of science that overcomes the traditional dualisms of epistemic subject and object as well as of nature and culture (science). Beyond scientific realism and radical social constructivism, Haraway understands 'nature' or 'world' neither as a passive resource nor as a human product of imagination. Rather, she argues, the world is to be understood as a 'witty agent' that has its own efficacy and historicity in the production of knowledge. Instead of epistemic reification, possession, and appropriation of 'nature', knowledge production should be understood as a conversation between material-semiotic actors, human, and non-human, from which none of the actors leaves as they entered. In this study, I want to explore what it means to conceive of nature or world in knowledge processes as a "witty agent" and how exactly one is to imagine this form of non-human agency. To this end, I will first explain Haraway's re-vision of "nature" beyond scientific realism and radical social constructivism (sect. 2). From this, I will discuss her underlying conception of agency (sect. 3). This involves first, a reconception of the traditional relation between epistemic subject and object as dynamic and situational relation (sect. 3.1). Second, Haraway characterizes the world's epistemic agency in more positive terms by using the 'trickster' figure as it appears in Southwest Native American representations in the form of a Coyote (sect. 3.2). Finally, I will come back to Haraway's initial question of an objective scientific approach to the world, which for her consists in a power-charged social relation of conversations with the world. I will conclude with a critical reflection of what Haraway's conception of the world as an agent means for scientific practice and its engagement with objects of knowledge.

摘要

在生物学家兼科学哲学家唐娜·哈拉维的论文《情境知识》中,她从女性主义视角探讨了科学客观性问题,并选择对科学进行“重新审视”,以克服认知主体与客体以及自然与文化(科学)之间的传统二元论。超越科学实在论和激进社会建构主义,哈拉维既不将“自然”或“世界”理解为被动资源,也不将其视为人类想象的产物。相反,她认为,世界应被理解为一个“机智的行动者”,在知识生产中具有自身的效力和历史性。知识生产不应是对“自然”的认知固化、占有和挪用,而应被理解为物质 - 符号行动者(包括人类和非人类)之间的对话,没有任何行动者能在对话结束时还保持其进入时的原样。在本研究中,我想探讨在知识过程中将自然或世界构想为“机智的行动者”意味着什么,以及究竟应如何想象这种非人类能动性的形式。为此,我将首先解释哈拉维超越科学实在论和激进社会建构主义对“自然”的重新审视(第2节)。据此,我将讨论她关于能动性的潜在概念(第3节)。这首先涉及将认知主体与客体之间的传统关系重新构想为动态的、情境化的关系(第3.1节)。其次,哈拉维通过以郊狼形象出现在美国西南部原住民表征中的“骗子”形象,更积极地描述了世界的认知能动性(第3.2节)。最后,我将回到哈拉维最初提出的关于以客观科学方法看待世界的问题,对她而言,这在于与世界进行充满权力的社会对话关系。我将以对哈拉维将世界构想为行动者的概念对科学实践及其与知识对象的互动意味着什么的批判性反思作为结论。

相似文献

8
EMPIRICISM IN LATTER-DAY BEHAVIORAL SCIENCE.当代行为科学中的经验主义。
Science. 1964 Jul 31;145(3631):464-7. doi: 10.1126/science.145.3631.464.

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验