Suppr超能文献

支持开放科学:临床和实验医学的进展和预印本。

Supporting open science: Advances in Clinical and Experimental Medicine and preprints.

机构信息

Managing Editor, Wroclaw Medical University Press, Poland.

Division of Research Methodology, Department of Nursing, Faculty of Nursing and Midwifery, Wroclaw Medical University, Poland.

出版信息

Adv Clin Exp Med. 2024 Oct;33(10):1045-1068. doi: 10.17219/acem/193956.

Abstract

This editorial outlines the issue of preprints in scholarly communication. It presents the policy regarding them in Advances in Clinical and Medical Problems and a summary of papers released as preprints and subsequently published in this journal or rejected until July 10, 2024. The introduction discusses the definition of preprint, and leading preprint servers are listed. Policies of 2 such services - Research Square and medRxiv - most frequently chosen by Adv Clin Exp Med authors are then described, followed by a broad outline of the advantages of preprints and controversies surrounding them, based on selected literature on this topic. The next section discusses the policies of most renowned medical journals and publishers regarding preprints. The preprint policy of Adv Clin Exp Med is then thoroughly explained, as well as its reasons. All papers previously released as preprints and published in this journal in 2021-2024 are presented, focusing on meaningful differences between them. Rejected papers previously released as preprints, submitted to Adv Clin Exp Med in 2022-2024, are also listed and discussed. The conclusion is that the basis for endorsing preprints in this journal is not that they benefit this journal but that they serve the scientific community as a whole and science in general by facilitating rapid dissemination of results and fostering immediate assessment of those results by other investigators and debate around them. The most justified line of action is educating authors about the benefits and problems related to preprints.

摘要

这篇社论概述了学术交流中预印本的问题。它介绍了《临床与医学进展》杂志对预印本的政策,以及截至 2024 年 7 月 10 日发布为预印本并随后在该杂志上发表或被拒绝的论文摘要。引言部分讨论了预印本的定义,并列出了主要的预印本服务器。然后描述了 Adv Clin Exp Med 作者最常选择的两个服务——Research Square 和 medRxiv 的政策,接着根据关于这个主题的文献综述,广泛概述了预印本的优势和围绕它们的争议。下一节讨论了大多数著名医学期刊和出版商对预印本的政策。然后详细解释了《临床与医学进展》杂志的预印本政策及其原因。本文还列出并讨论了所有之前作为预印本发布并在 2021-2024 年期间在该杂志上发表的论文,重点关注它们之间的显著差异。此外,还列出并讨论了 2022-2024 年期间提交给 Adv Clin Exp Med 的之前作为预印本发布但被拒绝的论文。结论是,支持该杂志发表预印本的基础不是它们对该杂志有益,而是它们通过促进研究结果的快速传播并促进其他研究人员对这些结果的即时评估以及围绕这些结果的辩论,为整个科学界和科学服务。最合理的行动方针是教育作者了解预印本相关的利益和问题。

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验