Zhu Kevin Y, Sun Kristie J, Breslin Mary A, Kalina Mark, Moon Tyler, Furdock Ryan, Vallier Heather A
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine, Cleveland, OH, USA.
Evellere Group, Cleveland, OH, USA.
J Trauma Inj. 2024 Mar;37(1):60-66. doi: 10.20408/jti.2023.0064. Epub 2024 Feb 26.
This study investigated changes in interpersonal violence and utilization of trauma recovery services during the COVID-19 pandemic. At an urban level I trauma center, trauma recovery services (TRS) provide education, counseling, peer support, and coordination of rehabilitation and recovery to address social and mental health needs. The COVID-19 pandemic prompted considerable changes in hospital services and increases in interpersonal victimization.
A retrospective analysis was conducted between September 6, 2018 and December 20, 2020 for 1,908 victim-of-crime patients, including 574 victims of interpersonal violence. Outcomes included length of stay associated with initial TRS presentation, number of subsequent emergency department visits, number of outpatient appointments, and utilization of specific specialties within the year following the initial traumatic event.
Patients were primarily female (59.4%), single (80.1%), non-Hispanic (86.7%), and Black (59.2%). The mean age was 33.0 years, and 247 patients (49.2%) presented due to physical assault, 132 (26.3%) due to gunshot wounds, and 76 (15.1%) due to sexual assault. The perpetrators were primarily partners (27.9%) or strangers (23.3%). During the study period, 266 patients (mean, 14.9 patients per month) presented before the declaration of COVID-19 as a national emergency on March 13, 2020, while 236 patients (mean, 25.9 patients per month) presented afterward, representing a 74.6% increase in victim-of-crime patients treated. Interactions with TRS decreased during the COVID-19 period, with an average of 3.0 interactions per patient before COVID-19 versus 1.9 after emergency declaration (P<0.01). Similarly, reductions in length of stay were noted; the pre-COVID-19 average was 3.6 days, compared to 2.1 days post-COVID-19 (P=0.01).
While interpersonal violence increased, TRS interactions decreased during the COVID-19 pandemic, reflecting interruption of services, COVID-19 precautions, and postponement/cancellation of elective visits. Future direction of hospital policy to enable resource and service delivery to this population, despite internal and external challenges, appears warranted.
本研究调查了2019年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)大流行期间人际暴力的变化以及创伤恢复服务的使用情况。在一家城市一级的I类创伤中心,创伤恢复服务(TRS)提供教育、咨询、同伴支持以及康复与恢复协调,以满足社会和心理健康需求。COVID-19大流行促使医院服务发生了重大变化,并导致人际伤害事件增加。
对2018年9月6日至2020年12月20日期间的1908名犯罪受害者患者进行了回顾性分析,其中包括574名人际暴力受害者。结果包括与首次接受TRS治疗相关的住院时间、随后的急诊就诊次数、门诊预约次数以及初次创伤事件后一年内特定专科的使用情况。
患者主要为女性(59.4%)、单身(80.1%)、非西班牙裔(86.7%)和黑人(59.2%)。平均年龄为33.0岁,247名患者(49.2%)因身体攻击就诊,132名(26.3%)因枪伤就诊,76名(15.1%)因性侵犯就诊。犯罪者主要是伴侣(27.9%)或陌生人(23.3%)。在研究期间,266名患者(平均每月14.9名患者)在2020年3月13日COVID-19被宣布为国家紧急情况之前就诊,而236名患者(平均每月25.9名患者)在此之后就诊,这表明接受治疗的犯罪受害者患者增加了74.6%。在COVID-19期间,与TRS的互动减少,COVID-19之前平均每名患者有3.0次互动,紧急声明之后为1.9次(P<0.01)。同样,住院时间也有所缩短;COVID-19之前的平均住院时间为3.6天,而COVID-19之后为2.1天(P=0.01)。
虽然人际暴力有所增加,但在COVID-19大流行期间,TRS互动减少,这反映了服务中断、COVID-19预防措施以及选择性就诊的推迟/取消。尽管存在内部和外部挑战,但医院政策的未来方向似乎有必要确保为这一人群提供资源和服务。