Alhelail Mohammed, Albelali Areej, Alkanhal Raghad, Salam Mahmoud
Emergency Medicine Department, King Abdulaziz Medical City, Ministry of National Guard-Health Affairs, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
King Abdullah International Medical Research Center, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
Toxicol Rep. 2024 Sep 24;13:101749. doi: 10.1016/j.toxrep.2024.101749. eCollection 2024 Dec.
Over the course of five years, 72,168 scorpion stings were recorded in Saudi Arabia. Though a number of articles have been published on scorpion stings in the country, no review studies have sought to determine the severity of scorpion envenomation using a standardized scale. The purpose of this systematic review is, thus, to explore the signs and symptoms of scorpion envenomation victims in Saudi Arabia and classify them using the Abroug's severity scale. This review identified 49 articles published between January 1953 and September 2024 on scorpion sting incidents in Saudi Arabia. Out of this total, 26 (53.1 %) articles met the systematic review criteria. The selected articles were reviewed by an emergency physician, a pediatrician, an assistant professor, and a consultant in toxicology, knowing that all examined articles were published in peer reviewed journals indexed in PubMed, EMBASE, Scopus, Web of science and CINAHL. Preset keywords and medical subject headings (MeSH terms) were used for the review. Three reviewed studies reported that 20-52 % of scorpion victims are asymptomatic. Other studies confirmed that Class I local manifestations, such as pain, erythema, swelling, and burning are present in the majority of scorpion sting victims (47.4-100 %). Class II systemic symptoms, such as hypertension, tachycardia, restlessness, cold extremities, gastrointestinal abnormalities and priapism, were reported in 15 studies, while bleeding was recorded in 2 patients in the same study. More complicated Class III cases manifested neurological deteriorations (seizures, neurotoxicity and unconsciousness), pulmonary edema, and pulmonary/cardiac arrest. Jointly, the studies revealed that a total of 16,745 scorpion sting victims were admitted and hospitalized for more than 24 h, and hospital stay duration varied, for all patients, between 3 h and 4 weeks. Around 1371 cases in six studies refused treatment and were discharged against medical advice. Fifteen victims across ten studies died from the scorpion stings. Children and patients with pre-existing clinical conditions generally reported more severe signs and symptoms. Study findings showed that practitioners should be aware of the early warning signs of pulmonary edema, cardiac toxicity and myocarditis, which are not uncommon post scorpion envenomation. Practitioners should also take into consideration that electrolyte imbalances might occur, but they do not usually pose serious clinical problems. Hemorrhages might happen, but they are mostly treatable. In conclusion, it is advised that practitioners utilize the standardized Abroug's classification for grading signs and symptoms of scorpion stings.
在五年的时间里,沙特阿拉伯共记录了72168例蝎子蜇伤事件。尽管该国已经发表了许多关于蝎子蜇伤的文章,但尚未有综述性研究试图使用标准化量表来确定蝎子蜇伤中毒的严重程度。因此,本系统综述的目的是探讨沙特阿拉伯蝎子蜇伤受害者的体征和症状,并使用阿布鲁格严重程度量表对其进行分类。本综述共检索到1953年1月至2024年9月间发表的49篇关于沙特阿拉伯蝎子蜇伤事件的文章。其中,26篇(53.1%)文章符合系统综述标准。选定的文章由一名急诊医生、一名儿科医生、一名助理教授和一名毒理学顾问进行评审,所有被审查的文章均发表在被PubMed、EMBASE、Scopus、科学网和CINAHL索引的同行评审期刊上。本次综述使用了预设的关键词和医学主题词(MeSH词)。三项综述性研究报告称,20%-52%的蝎子蜇伤受害者没有症状。其他研究证实,大多数蝎子蜇伤受害者(47.4%-100%)出现I级局部表现,如疼痛、红斑、肿胀和烧灼感。15项研究报告了II级全身症状,如高血压、心动过速、烦躁不安、四肢冰冷、胃肠道异常和阴茎异常勃起,同一研究中有2例患者出现出血症状。更复杂的III级病例表现为神经功能恶化(癫痫发作、神经毒性和昏迷)、肺水肿以及肺/心搏骤停。这些研究共同表明,共有16745名蝎子蜇伤受害者入院并住院超过24小时,所有患者的住院时间在3小时至4周之间。六项研究中的约1371例患者拒绝治疗并自行出院。十项研究中的15名受害者死于蝎子蜇伤。儿童和已有临床疾病的患者通常报告有更严重的体征和症状。研究结果表明,从业者应了解肺水肿、心脏毒性和心肌炎的早期预警信号,这些在蝎子蜇伤后并不罕见。从业者还应考虑到可能会出现电解质失衡,但通常不会造成严重的临床问题。可能会发生出血,但大多是可以治疗的。总之,建议从业者使用标准化的阿布鲁格分类法对蝎子蜇伤的体征和症状进行分级。