Department of Urology, Rush University Medical Center, 1725 W. Harrison Street, Suite 970, Chicago, IL, 60612, USA.
Department of Maternal-Child and Urological Sciences, Sapienza University Rome, Policlinico Umberto I Hospital, Rome, Italy.
J Robot Surg. 2024 Oct 14;18(1):369. doi: 10.1007/s11701-024-02120-4.
Our aim was to investigate the perception and future expectations of Single-Port (SP) surgery among urology trainees in the United States. A 34-item online survey was distributed to urological residency and fellowship programs across the US, covering demographic profiles, SP training opportunities, perceived educational impact, and future perspectives. Descriptive analysis and multivariable linear regression were used to assess predictors of SP adoption. 201 surveys were completed (28.6% completion rate). Among institutions with an SP platform, about 50% have used it regularly for over 2 years, though often in less than 50% of procedures. While robotic simulators are commonly available, only 17% offer both multi-port and SP simulators, and structured pre-clinical SP training is limited. Approximately 30% of respondents expressed concerns over limited hands-on experience and a steeper learning curve with SP. Around 40% felt that their robotic surgery exposure was negatively impacted by SP's introduction. SP surgery's benefits are seen mostly in the immediate post-operative period and a significant number of respondents foresee a major role for SP in urology. However, proficiency in SP surgery is not seen as crucial for career advancement or job opportunities. Academic job aspirations, SP platform availability, and SP surgery workload are predictors of future SP implementation. Trainees increasingly recognize the clinical benefits of SP procedures but express concerns about the potential negative impact on hands-on experience. Training programs should more systematically integrate SP technology into curricula. There is a correlation between training in high-volume SP centers and future SP adoption.
我们旨在调查美国泌尿科住院医师对单端口(SP)手术的认知和未来期望。我们向美国各地的泌尿科住院医师和研究员计划分发了一份包含 34 个项目的在线调查,涵盖人口统计学概况、SP 培训机会、感知教育影响和未来展望。我们使用描述性分析和多变量线性回归来评估 SP 采用的预测因素。共完成了 201 项调查(完成率为 28.6%)。在拥有 SP 平台的机构中,约有 50%的机构已经将其常规用于超过 2 年的时间,尽管通常不到 50%的手术中使用。虽然机器人模拟器通常是可用的,但只有 17%的机构提供多端口和 SP 模拟器,并且结构化的临床前 SP 培训是有限的。约 30%的受访者对有限的实践经验和 SP 陡峭的学习曲线表示担忧。约 40%的人认为他们的机器人手术暴露会因 SP 的引入而受到负面影响。SP 手术的好处主要在术后即刻期间显现,相当数量的受访者预见到 SP 在泌尿科中的重要作用。然而,SP 手术的熟练程度并不被视为职业发展或工作机会的关键。学术工作愿望、SP 平台的可用性和 SP 手术工作量是未来 SP 实施的预测因素。住院医师越来越认识到 SP 手术的临床益处,但对潜在的实践经验负面影响表示担忧。培训计划应更系统地将 SP 技术纳入课程。在高容量 SP 中心进行培训与未来 SP 采用之间存在相关性。