Professor, Department of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry, AME's Dental College and Hospital, Raichur, Karnataka, India.
Head, Department of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry, AME's Dental College and Hospital, Raichur, Karnataka, India.
Pediatr Dent. 2024 Sep 15;46(5):306-311.
To compare the efficacy of laser phototherapy, Buzzy®, and lignocaine gel in minimizing pain during intraoral injections. In this randomized controlled trial, the efficacy of standard lignocaine gel (Group A) was compared with Buzzy® (Group B) and laser phototherapy (Group C) as pre-anesthetic agents in 15 children aged eight to 12 years undergoing intraoral local anesthesia (LA). Pain perception during needle insertion was assessed objectively using the Face, Legs, Activity, Cry, Consolability (FLACC) scale and subjectively using the Visual Analogue Scale (VAS). Statistical analysis included chi-square and analysis of variance tests (P<0.05). Objective assessment of pain perception using FLACC scores demonstrated that Buzzy® resulted in the highest comfort levels; 60 percent of the subjects treated with Buzzy®, 40 percent treated with laser phototherapy, and 6.7 percent treated with lignocaine topical anesthetic were judged to be relaxed and comfortable or exhibiting mild discomfort, respectively. Subjective pain assessment (self-reported using the VAS) was significantly lower in Buzzy® (0.67±0.82 standard deviation) followed by laser phototherapy (1.00±1.13) and Lignocaine gel group (2.13±1.51). The Buzzy® and laser phototherapy effectively reduced intraoral injection pain compared to the standard control, lignocaine gel. However, Buzzy® showed better efficacy.
比较激光光疗、Buzzy®和利多卡因凝胶在减轻口腔内注射疼痛中的效果。在这项随机对照试验中,比较了标准利多卡因凝胶(A 组)、Buzzy®(B 组)和激光光疗(C 组)作为 8-12 岁接受口腔局部麻醉(LA)的 15 名儿童的麻醉前药物。使用面部、腿部、活动、哭泣、安抚(FLACC)量表和视觉模拟量表(VAS)对疼痛感知进行客观和主观评估。统计分析包括卡方检验和方差分析(P<0.05)。使用 FLACC 评分对疼痛感知进行客观评估显示,Buzzy®产生的舒适度最高;60%的 Buzzy®治疗组、40%的激光光疗组和 6.7%的利多卡因局部麻醉组被认为是放松和舒适或仅表现出轻度不适。Buzzy®(0.67±0.82 标准差)的主观疼痛评估(使用 VAS 自我报告)明显低于激光光疗(1.00±1.13)和利多卡因凝胶组(2.13±1.51)。Buzzy®和激光光疗与标准对照利多卡因凝胶相比,有效地减轻了口腔内注射疼痛。然而,Buzzy®的效果更好。