Kolb Samuel, Patel Puja, Mudrakola Vishnu, Nikolla Dhimitri A, Lee Amanda, Barbour Dusty, Bowers Kaitlin M
Department of Emergency Medicine, Jerry M. Wallace School of Osteopathic Medicine, Campbell University, Lillington, USA.
Department of Emergency Medicine, Summa Health, Akron, USA.
Cureus. 2024 Sep 17;16(9):e69603. doi: 10.7759/cureus.69603. eCollection 2024 Sep.
Mass casualty incident (MCI) training effectively increases trainees' knowledge and confidence when implemented in a live, in-person setting. In-person MCI training is resource-intensive, but virtual MCI training models are an alternative with similar effectiveness at a lesser cost. However, most of these validated virtual options are based on high-tech virtual reality (VR) programs. We designed and implemented a low-tech, low-cost virtual MCI training model for third-year medical students, using Google Jamboard (Google, Mountain View, CA) and Zoom (Zoom Video Communications, Inc., San Jose, CA) as the primary technological platforms.
Learners were instructed on the adult simple triage and rapid treatment (START) and the pediatric JumpSTART triage algorithms over Zoom. In small groups, students used a gameboard on Google Jamboard to simulate a scene at an MCI where they were tasked with triaging 25 patients in 30 minutes, followed by a debriefing session. Students were surveyed on their perceived understanding of the triage algorithms and confidence before and after the event using a 5-point Likert scale (poor, fair, good, very good, and excellent). Pre- and post-event scores were compared using paired, two-sample, and two-tailed t-tests. We considered a p value of <0.01 significant to correct for multiplicity using the Bonferroni method.
Learners reported an increased understanding of the triage algorithms (adult and pediatric), scene setup, and understanding of emergency medical service training/transportation, as well as increased confidence in participating in an MCI (all p < 0.001).
Virtual MCI training can be used as an alternative or supplement to in-person MCI training. Low-tech virtual MCI training models can increase the accessibility of these valuable training activities without sacrificing the quality of learning. Areas for further investigation include low-tech virtual MCI training models' ability to effectively recreate situational and environmental distractions and other challenges better simulated by in-person and high-tech VR training events.
大规模伤亡事件(MCI)培训在现场面对面的环境中实施时,能有效增加学员的知识和信心。面对面的MCI培训资源密集,但虚拟MCI培训模式是一种替代方案,效果相似且成本较低。然而,大多数经过验证的虚拟选项都基于高科技虚拟现实(VR)程序。我们为三年级医学生设计并实施了一种低成本、低技术的虚拟MCI培训模式,主要使用谷歌Jamboard(谷歌公司,加利福尼亚州山景城)和Zoom(Zoom视频通讯公司,加利福尼亚州圣何塞)作为技术平台。
通过Zoom向学习者讲授成人简单分诊与快速治疗(START)和儿科JumpSTART分诊算法。学生们分组使用谷歌Jamboard上的游戏板模拟MCI现场场景,他们的任务是在30分钟内对25名患者进行分诊,随后进行汇报总结。使用5分李克特量表(差、一般、好、非常好、优秀)对学生在活动前后对分诊算法的理解和信心进行调查。使用配对、双样本和双尾t检验比较活动前后的分数。我们认为p值<0.01具有统计学意义,并使用Bonferroni方法校正多重性。
学习者报告称,他们对分诊算法(成人和儿科)、场景设置以及对紧急医疗服务培训/运输的理解有所增加,并且参与MCI的信心也有所增强(所有p<0.001)。
虚拟MCI培训可作为面对面MCI培训的替代或补充。低成本、低技术的虚拟MCI培训模式可以提高这些有价值的培训活动的可及性,而不牺牲学习质量。需要进一步研究的领域包括低成本、低技术的虚拟MCI培训模式有效重现情景和环境干扰以及其他由面对面和高科技VR培训活动更好模拟挑战的能力。