McGill Sarah C
Research Information Specialist, Research Information Services, Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health (CADTH), Ottawa, ON.
J Can Health Libr Assoc. 2024 Aug 1;45(2):88-97. doi: 10.29173/jchla29741. eCollection 2024 Aug.
This paper describes the search approach for preprints for a post COVID-19 condition (i.e., long COVID) scoping review, including source selection, search strategy development, challenges, and insights throughout a project life cycle. With the growth of medical preprints since the COVID-19 pandemic, information professionals and researchers should be aware that preprints are possible sources of evidence and be prepared to manage them in evidence reviews for COVID-19 topics and beyond. Preprints are not peer-reviewed but can include important evidence about emerging topics. Because of the importance of preprints to the scoping review, a preprint search of Europe PubMed Central (PMC) was added. Europe PMC and similar aggregators combine multiple preprint servers and often have Boolean search, but sometimes limited search functionalities or few export options. Strategy translation encountered challenges such as varying and inconsistent terminology for post-COVID-19 condition, a complex search, and negotiating large numbers of preprints with resource constraints. Europe PMC identified additional preprints for inclusion due to additional preprint server coverage. It was helpful to limit the preprint search to the title and abstract fields, and to run an extra Internet search for publication of included study preprints. Challenges and potential solutions are summarized to support those conducting preprint searches for COVID-19 and other topics.
本文描述了针对新冠后状况(即长期新冠)范围综述的预印本检索方法,包括来源选择、检索策略制定、挑战以及整个项目生命周期中的见解。自新冠疫情大流行以来,随着医学预印本数量的增加,信息专业人员和研究人员应意识到预印本可能是证据来源,并准备好在针对新冠及其他主题的证据综述中对其进行管理。预印本未经同行评审,但可能包含有关新出现主题的重要证据。由于预印本对范围综述很重要,因此增加了对欧洲 PubMed 中心(Europe PMC)的预印本检索。欧洲 PMC 及类似的聚合器整合了多个预印本服务器,通常具备布尔检索功能,但有时检索功能有限或导出选项较少。策略转换遇到了一些挑战,例如新冠后状况的术语多变且不一致、检索复杂,以及在资源受限的情况下处理大量预印本。由于额外的预印本服务器覆盖范围,欧洲 PMC 识别出了更多纳入的预印本。将预印本检索限制在标题和摘要字段,并对纳入研究预印本的发表进行额外的互联网检索很有帮助。总结了挑战和潜在解决方案,以支持那些针对新冠及其他主题进行预印本检索的人员。