Brunel University London, Uxbridge, UK.
J Prim Care Community Health. 2024 Jan-Dec;15:21501319241291786. doi: 10.1177/21501319241291786.
The high prevalence of dementia among Black Africans, coupled with their lower engagement with dementia specialist services in the UK, underscores the urgency of understanding lay knowledge and beliefs about dementia in the group. Studies reporting lay knowledge of dementia in the UK tended to conclude that Black Africans lack dementia knowledge, presumably based on biomedical assumptions, without taking into consideration the Black Africans' lay dementia knowledge and beliefs about dementia. The current study, therefore, investigated the Black African populations' lay knowledge and beliefs toward dementia in Africa, comparing how this relates to the findings in the UK literature. Methodology: The researcher thoroughly searched electronic databases from September 2017 to October 2022 for qualitative research exploring how Black African populations perceived and experienced dementia, which informed the Black Africans' dementia knowledge in Africa and the UK. The review included qualitative studies with African populations published in peer-reviewed journals with available abstracts and full text in English. Studies outside the UK and Africa, as well as quantitative research and studies with health practitioners, were excluded. A grounded theory approach informed the thematic analysis. The researcher reported the Black Africans' lay knowledge and beliefs toward dementia, informed by participants' experiences and meanings of dementia. Results: Twenty-two studies (n = 22) met the eligibility criteria and were appraised and included in the review. All the UK papers were a multi-modeling of ethnicity in the study. Nine studies (n = 9) were conducted in the UK. Thirteen studies (n = 13) are conducted in Africa, (5 [n = 5] studies from South Africa, 2 [n = 2] from Tanzania, 1 [n = 1] from Congo, 2 [n = 2] from Uganda, 2 [n = 2] from Nigeria, and 1 [n = 1] from Ghana). All the studies were valuable. The researcher identified and developed 4 themes as they emerged from the studies: (i) Dementia witchcraft paradigm, (ii) Dementia older age paradigm, (iii) Dementia disease and illness paradigm, and (iv) Dementia identity paradigm. Discussion/Conclusion: The lay knowledge and beliefs about dementia among Black African populations were foregrounded in sociocultural distinctiveness, and some understanding intersected with biomedical knowledge about dementia. Further empirical study in the UK is essential. Implications for policy and practice: A better understanding of lay knowledge and beliefs about dementia among Black African populations can improve dementia care, providing culturally sensitive and tailored support for Black African communities.
黑种非洲人痴呆症的高发率,加上他们在英国与痴呆症专家服务的接触较少,这突显了迫切需要了解该群体中关于痴呆症的通俗知识和信仰。在英国,报告关于痴呆症的通俗知识的研究往往得出结论认为,黑种非洲人缺乏痴呆症知识,这大概是基于生物医学假设,而没有考虑到黑种非洲人关于痴呆症的通俗知识和信仰。因此,本研究调查了非洲黑种人群对痴呆症的通俗知识和信仰,比较了这与英国文献中的发现有何关联。
研究人员从 2017 年 9 月到 2022 年 10 月,彻底搜索电子数据库,以寻找探索黑种非洲人群如何看待和经历痴呆症的定性研究,这些研究为非洲和英国的黑种非洲人痴呆症知识提供了信息。该综述包括在同行评议期刊上发表的针对非洲人群的定性研究,这些期刊的摘要和全文都可以用英语获取。研究范围不包括英国和非洲以外的研究、定量研究以及针对卫生保健从业者的研究。扎根理论方法为主题分析提供了信息。研究人员报告了黑种非洲人对痴呆症的通俗知识和信仰,这是基于参与者对痴呆症的体验和认知。
22 项研究(n=22)符合入选标准,并经过评估后纳入综述。英国所有论文都在研究中对种族进行了多模式建模。9 项研究(n=9)在英国进行。13 项研究(n=13)在非洲进行,其中 5 项(n=5)来自南非,2 项(n=2)来自坦桑尼亚,1 项(n=1)来自刚果,2 项(n=2)来自乌干达,2 项(n=2)来自尼日利亚,1 项(n=1)来自加纳。所有研究都很有价值。研究人员从研究中确定并开发了 4 个主题:(i)痴呆症巫术范式,(ii)痴呆症老年范式,(iii)痴呆症疾病和疾病范式,以及(iv)痴呆症身份范式。
讨论/结论:黑种非洲人群对痴呆症的通俗知识和信仰突出了社会文化的独特性,其中一些理解与痴呆症的生物医学知识相交。在英国进一步进行实证研究至关重要。
更好地了解黑种非洲人群对痴呆症的通俗知识和信仰,可以改善痴呆症护理,为黑种非洲社区提供文化敏感和量身定制的支持。